Wednesday, September 30, 2009

TNA Star Ratings List


All ratings were taken from Dave Meltzer's "Wrestling Observer Newsletter". All dates listed are the original dates that the matches aired on television. Thanks to Todd Packard for his contributions.

Please visit http://www.wrestlingobserver.com for more information on the wrestling observer newsletter.

2002

6/19/02 Low Ki/Jerry Lynn/AJ Styles vs. Sonny Siaki/Jimmy Yang/Jorge Estrada ***3/4
6/19/02 Ken Shamrock vs. Malice ***
6/26/02 Low Ki vs. Jerry Lynn vs. AJ Styles vs. Psicosis (Elimination) ****1/2
7/10/02 Christopher Daniels vs. Low Ki vs. Kid Romeo vs. Jerry Lynn vs. Tony Mamaluke vs. Elix Skipper ***1/2
8/7/02 Low Ki vs. Jerry Lynn vs. AJ Styles ****1/2
8/28/02 AJ Styles vs. Jerry Lynn vs. Low Ki (Ladder) ****1/4
10/2/02 AJ Styles vs. Jerry Lynn (Ladder) ***3/4
10/16/02 AJ Styles vs. Syxx-Pac ***1/4
10/23/02 AJ Styles vs. Syxx-Pac ***1/2
10/30/02 AJ Styles vs. The Amazing Red ***3/4
11/6/02 AJ Styles vs. Jerry Lynn ****
11/20/02 Ron Killings vs. Jeff Jarrett ***1/2
11/27/02 AJ Styles vs. Jerry Lynn ***1/2

2003

2/5/03 Elix Skipper/Low Ki vs. Brian Lee/Slash ***
2/19/03 AJ Styles vs. Jeff Jarrett ***3/4
2/26/03 Juventud Guerrera vs. Jerry Lynn ***3/4
3/5/03 Jerry Lynn vs. Super Crazy ***3/4
4/9/03 Amazing Red/Jerry Lynn vs. Christopher Daniels/Elix Skipper vs. Jonny Storm/Chris Sabin vs. Jason Cross/Shark Boy ****
4/16/03 Jerry Lynn/Amazing Red vs. Christopher Daniels/Elix Skipper ****
6/18/03 Chris Sabin vs. Paul London ***1/4
6/18/03 Christopher Daniels/Elix Skipper vs. Chris Harris/James Storm ***1/2
6/25/03 Christopher Daniels/Elix Skipper vs. Chris Harris/James Storm (Cage) ****1/4
7/9/03 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Simon Diamond/Johnny Swinger ***1/2
7/30/03 Chris Sabin vs. Michael Shane ***1/2
8/6/03 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Simon Diamond/Johnny Swinger (Strap) ***1/2
8/27/03 AJ Styles vs. Raven ****
9/3/03 Teddy Hart vs. Juventud Guerrera ****1/4
9/3/03 Juventud Guerrera vs. Chris Sabin ****1/2

2004

2/11/04 Juventud Guerrera vs. Chris Sabin ***3/4
2/11/04 Juventud Guerrera/Mr. Aguila/Abismo Negro/Hector Garza vs. Chris Sabin/Sonjay Dutt/Jerry Lynn/Elix Skipper (Elimination) ***3/4
7/21/04 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Chase Stevens/Andy Douglas (Cage) ****
11/7/04 X-Division Rumble ****
11/7/04 Petey Williams vs. AJ Styles ***3/4
11/10/04 Chris Sabin vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Elix Skipper (Ultimate X) ****
12/5/04 Hector Garza/Sonny Siaki/Sonjay Dutt vs. Michael Shane/Frankie Kazarian/Kid Kash ***1/4
12/5/04 Diamond Dallas Page vs. Raven ***1/4
12/5/04 Petey Williams vs. Chris Sabin ****
12/5/04 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Christopher Daniels/Elix Skipper (Cage) ****3/4

2005

1/16/05 Elix Skipper vs. Sonjay Dutt ***1/4
1/16/05 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Bobby Roode/Eric Young ****1/2
1/16/05 AJ Styles vs. Petey Williams vs. Chris Sabin (Ultimate X) ****1/2
1/16/05 Jeff Jarrett vs. Monty Brown ***
2/13/05 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Kid Kash/Lance Hoyt ***1/2
2/13/05 Diamond Dallas Page/Monty Brown vs. Eric Young/Bobby Roode ***
2/13/05 AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels (30-Minute Iron Man) ****3/4
3/13/05 Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles vs. Elix Skipper vs. Ron Killings ***3/4
4/24/05 Shocker vs. Michael Shane vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Chris Sabin (Cage-Elimination) ***1/2
4/24/05 Raven vs. Jeff Hardy ***1/4 (Cage-Table)
4/24/05 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Petey Williams/Eric Young (Cage) ***1/2
4/24/05 Christopher Daniels vs. Elix Skipper (Cage) ***1/4
4/24/05 AJ Styles vs. Abyss (Cage) ****1/4
5/15/05 Raven vs. Sean Waltman (Clockwork Orange House of Fun) ***1/4
5/15/05 Andy Douglas/Chase Stevens vs. Chris Harris/James Storm ***
5/15/05 Christopher Daniels vs. Shocker ***1/4
5/15/05 Gauntlet Match ***
5/15/05 AJ Styles vs. Jeff Jarrett ***
6/19/05 Shark Boy vs. Delirious vs. Zach Gowen vs.
Jerrelle Clark vs. Amazing Red vs. Elix Skipper (Elimination) ***1/4
6/19/05 Shocker vs. Alex Shelley ***1/4
6/19/05 Christopher Daniels vs. Michael Shane vs. Chris Sabin ***1/4
6/19/05 Raven vs. AJ Styles vs. Abyss vs. Sean Waltman vs. Monty Brown (King of the Mountain) ***
7/17/05 Sonjay Dutt vs. Mikey Batts vs. Shark Boy vs. Elix Skipper ***
7/17/05 Samoa Joe vs. Chris Sabin ****1/4
7/17/05 Eric Young/Bobby Roode/A-1 vs. Andy Douglas/Chase Stevens/Lance Hoyt ***1/2
7/17/05 AJ Styles vs. Sean Waltman ****
Christopher Daniels vs. Petey Williams ***3/4
7/17/05 Raven vs. Abyss (Dog Collar) ***1/2
8/15/05 Chrisopher Daniels vs. Austin Aries ***
8/15/05 Jerry Lynn vs. Sean Waltman ***3/4
8/15/05 Eric Young/Bobby Roode/Petey Williams/A-1 vs. Chris Harris/James Storm/Andy Douglas/Chase Stevens ***1/4
8/15/05 Samoa Joe vs. AJ Styles ****1/4
8/15/05 Jeff Jarrett/Rhino vs. Raven/Sabu ***1/2
9/11/05 Austin Aries vs. Roderick Strong ***1/2
9/11/05 Petey Williams vs. Chris Sabin ***
9/11/05 Andy Douglas/Chase Stevens vs. Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Eric Young/A-1 vs. Alex Shelley/Johnny Candito (Elimination) ***
9/11/05 AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels *****
10/23/05 Austin Aries vs. Roderick Strong vs. Alex Shelley vs. Sonjay Dutt ***1/2
10/23/05 Petey Williams vs. Chris Sabin vs. Matt Bentley (Ultimate X) ***
10/23/05 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Andy Douglas/Chase Stevens ***
10/23/05 Abyss vs. Rhyno vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Sabu (Monsters Ball) ****
10/23/05 AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels ****
11/3/05 Samoa Joe/Christopher Daniels/Alex Shelley vs. AJ Styles/Sonjay Dutt/Austin Aries ****
11/3/05 Petey Williams vs. Chris Sabin vs. Matt Bentley (Ultimate X) ***3/4
11/13/05 Christopher Daniels/Samoa Joe/Roderick Strong/Alex Shelley vs. Austin Aries/Chris Sabin/Matt Bentley/Sonjay Dutt (Elimination X) ***3/4
11/13/05 AJ Styles vs. Petey Williams ***3/4
11/13/05 Jeff Jarrett/Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Rhino/Brother Ray/Brother Devon ****
12/11/05 Samoa Joe vs. AJ Styles ****3/4
12/11/05 Jeff Jarrett vs. Rhino ***1/2

2006

1/15/06 Austin Aries/Roderick Strong/Alex Shelley vs. Sonjay Dutt/Matt Bentley/Chris Sabin ***
1/15/06 AJ Styles vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi ***
1/15/06 Chris Harris/James Strom vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/4
1/15/06 Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels ****1/4
2/12/06 Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Chris Sabin/Sonjay Dutt ***
2/12/06 Abyss vs. Rhyno (Falls Count Anywhere) ***3/4
2/12/06 Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles ****1/4
2/12/06 Brother Ray/Brother D-Von vs. Eric Young/Bobby Roode ***1/4
2/12/06 Christian Cage vs. Jeff Jarrett ***1/4
3/12/06 Chris Sabin vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Puma vs. Petey Williams ****
Jeff Jarrett/Abyss/Chris Harris/James Storm vs. Ron Killings/Brother Ray/Brother Devon/Rhyno ***1/2
3/12/06 Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles (Ultimate X) ***1/2
4/13/06 Samoa Joe vs. Christopher Daniels ****1/4
4/23/06 Hirooki Goto/Minoru/Black Tiger vs. Jay Lethal/Alex Shelley/Sonjay Dutt (cage) ***1/4
4/23/06 Christopher Daniels vs. Senshi (Cage) ***1/2
4/23/06 Chris Sabin vs. Puma vs. Shark Boy vs. Elix Skipper vs. Petey Williams vs. Chase Stevens (cage) ***1/2
4/23/06 Christian Cage vs. Abyss (cage) ***3/4
4/23/06 Sting/AJ Stylles/Ron Killings/Rhino vs. Jeff Jarrett/Scott Steiner/Chris Harris/James Storm (Lethal Lockdown) ***1/2
5/14/06 Chirs Harris/James Storm vs. AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels ***3/4
5/14/06 X-Cup Gauntlet ***1/4
5/14/06 Sting/Samoa Joe vs. Scott Steiner/Jeff Jarrett ***1/4
6/18/06 Brother Ray/Brother D-Von vs. Kip James/BG James (Bingo Hall Brawl) ***1/4
6/18/06 Senshi vs. Jay Lethal vs. Shark Boy vs. Petey Williams vs. Alex Shelley vs. Sonjay Dutt (Elimination) ***1/4
6/18/06 AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels vs. James Storm/Chris Harris ***3/4
6/18/06 Samoa Joe vs. Scott Steiner ***1/4
6/18/06 Christian Cage vs. Sting vs. Abyss vs. Jeff Jarrett vs. Ron Killings (King of the Mountain) ***
7/16/06 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Sonjay Dutt/Ron Killings ***1/2
8/13/06 Abyss vs. Brother Runt ***
8/13/06 Samoa Joe vs. Rhino vs. Monty Brown (Falls Count Anywhere) ****1/4
8/13/06 AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels vs. Homicide/Hernandez ***3/4
9/24/06 Christian Cage vs. Rhino ***1/4
9/24/06 AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels vs. Homicide/Hernandez (Ultimate X) ****
10/22/06 Samoa Joe vs. Raven vs. Abyss vs. Brother Runt (Monster's Ball) ***
10/22/06 Senshi vs. Chris Sabin ****
10/22/06 Christian Cage vs. Rhino (Eight Mile Street Fight) ***1/4
10/22/06 AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels vs. Homicide/Hernandez (Six Sides of Steel) ****
11/16/06 Christian Cage vs. Rhino (Barbed Wire Steel Cage) ***1/2
11/16/06 Abyss vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
11/19/06 Christopher Daniels vs. Chris Sabin ***1/2
11/19/06 Christian Cage vs. AJ Styles ***3/4
11/19/06 Kurt Angle vs. Samoa Joe ****1/4
12/10/06 Senshi vs. Austin Starr vs. Alex Shelley vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Jay Lethal (Elimination) ***1/4
12/10/06 Christopher Daniels vs. Chris Sabin ***
12/10/06 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Chris Harris/James Storm (Ladder Flag Match) ***1/4
12/10/06 Samoa Joe vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4

2007

1/14/07 Rhino vs. AJ Styles (Last Man Standing) ***
1/14/07 Chris Sabin vs. Jerry Lynn vs. Christopher Daniels ***1/4
1/14/07 Samoa Joe vs. Kurt Angle (30 Minute Iron Man) ***1/2
1/14/07 Christian Cage vs. Sting vs. Abyss ***1/4
2/11/07 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Brother Ray/Brother D-Von (Little Italy Street Fight) ***1/4
2/11/07 Chris Sabin vs. Jerry Lynn ***
2/11/07 Sting vs. Abyss (Prison Yard Match) ***1/4
2/11/07 Christian Cage vs. Kurt Angle ***1/2
3/11/2007 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Brother Ray/Brother D-Von (Street Fight) ***1/2
3/11/2007 Senshi vs. Austin Starr ***1/4
3/11/2007 Christian Cage vs. Samoa Joe ****
4/15/07 Chris Sabin vs. Alex Shelley vs. Shark Boy vs. Jay Lethal vs. Sonjay Dutt (Escape Cage) ***1/2
4/15/07 Austin Starr vs. Senshi (Cage) ***
4/15/07 Christian Cage/Tomko/Abyss/Scott Steiner/AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle/Sting/Samoa Joe/Rhino/Jeff Jarrett (Lethal Lockdown) ****
5/13/07 Chris Sabin vs. Jay Lethal vs. Sonjay Dutt ****
5/13/07 Robert Roode vs. Jeff Jarrett ***1/4
5/13/07 Chris Harris vs. James Storm (Texas Death) ****1/4
5/13/07 Jerry Lynn vs. Alex Shelley vs. Senshi vs. Tiger Mask ***1/2
5/13/07 Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. Homicide/Hernandez vs. Tomko/Scott Steiner ***
5/13/07 Samoa Joe vs. AJ Styles ***1/2
5/13/07 Christian Cage vs. Kurt Angle vs. Sting ***1/4
6/7/07 Chris Harris vs. James Storm ***3/4
6/17/07 Rhino/Senshi vs. Homicide/Hernandez ***1/4
6/17/07 Jay Lethal vs. Chris Sabin ***1/2
6/17/07 Eric Young vs. Robert Roode ***
6/17/07 Samoa Joe vs. AJ Styles vs. Chris Harris vs. Christian Cage vs. Kurt Angle (King of the Mountain) ****1/4
7/5/2007 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels ***1/2
7/15/07 Christopher Daniels vs. Jay Lethal vs. Puma vs. Homicide vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Petey Williams vs. Shark Boy vs. Elix Skipper vs. Frankie Kazarian vs. Senshi (Gauntlet/Ultimate X) ***1/2
7/15/07 Eric Young/Gail Kim vs. Traci Brooks/Robert Roode ***
7/15/07 Chris Harris vs. Christian Cage ***1/4
7/15/07 Samoa Joe/Kurt Angle vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/2
8/12/07 Jay Lethal/Sonjay Dutt vs. Christopher Daniels/Senshi vs. Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin ***1/2
8/12/07 Samoa Joe vs. Kurt Angle ***1/4
9/9/07 Rhino vs. James Storm ***1/4
9/9/07 Kaz vs. Robert Roode ***1/2
9/9/07 Jay Lethal vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
9/9/07 Samoa Joe vs. Christian Cage ***1/2
9/9/07 Kurt Angle vs. Abyss ***1/2
10/4/07 Junior Fatu/Samoa Joe/Homicide/Hernandez vs. Senshi/Christopher Daniels/Christian Cage/AJ Styles ***3/4
10/14/07 Senshi/Elix Skipper vs. Homicide/Hernandez (Ultimate X) ***3/4
10/14/07 Ron Killings/Rasheed Lucius Creed vs. Travis Tomko/AJ Styles ***1/4
10/14/07 Christopher Daniels vs. Jay Lethal ***1/2
10/14/07 Samoa Joe vs. Christian Cage ****
10/14/07 Kurt Angle vs. Sting ***3/4
10/25/07 Christian Cage vs. Samoa Joe ***1/2
11/1/07 Homicide/Hernandez vs. AJ Styles/Travis Tomko ***
11/8/07 Christian Cage vs. Kaz ***1/2
11/11/07 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/2
11/11/07 Jay Lethal vs. Sonjay Dutt ***1/4
11/11/07 Samoa Joe vs. Robert Roode ***
11/11/07 Kaz vs. Christian Cage (Ladder) ****
12/2/07 Gail Kim vs. Awesome Kong ***1/4
12/2/07 Booker T/Kaz vs. Christian/Robert Roode ***1/4
12/6/07 Samoa Joe/Kevin Nash/Kaz/Booker T/Eric Young vs. Kurt Angle/Christian Cage/AJ Styles/Travis Tomko/Robert Roode ***3/4
12/22/07 AJ Styles vs. Kaz (Ladder) ***1/2

2008

1/6/08 Gail Kim vs. Awesome Kong ***1/2
1/6/08 Samoa Joe/Kevin Nash vs. AJ Styles/Travis Tomko ***1/4
1/6/08 Kurt Angle vs. Christian Cage ***3/4
1/10/08 Gail Kim vs. Awesome Kong ***
1/17/08 Yuji Nagata vs. Kurt Angle ****
1/17/08 Samoa Joe vs. Christian Cage vs. AJ Styles ***1/4
2/10/08 Eric Yong vs. James Strong (TNA Drinking Championship) ***
2/10/08 Abyss vs. Judas Mesias (Barbed Wire Massacre Match) ***1/4
2/10/08 Jay Lethal/Alex Shelly/Chris Sabin vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon/Johnny Devine (Street Fight) ***1/2
2/10/08 Christian Cage vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
3/9/08 Homicide/Hernandez vs. Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Lance Hoyt/Jimmy Rave ***1/2
3/9/08 Jay Lethal vs. Petey Williams ***1/4
3/9/08 Awesome Kong vs. Gail Kim vs. ODB ***1/2
3/9/08 Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. Curry Man/Shark Boy (Fish Market Street Fight) ***
4/13/08 Jay Lethal vs. Curry man vs. Shark Boy vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Consequences Creed vs. Johnny Devine (Cage) ***
4/13/08 Christian Cage/Kevin Nash/Sting/Rhino/Matt Morgan vs. Tomko/AJ Styles/Brother Ray/Brother Devon/James Storm (Lethal Lockdown) ***3/4
4/13/08 Kurt Angle vs. Samoa Joe (Cage) ****1/4
4/24/08 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Christian Cage/Rhino ***1/4
4/24/08 Samoa Joe vs. Kurt Angle ***1/2
5/11/08 Kaz vs. Curry Man vs. Jay Lethal vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Consequences Creed vs. Jimmy Rave vs. Alex Shelley vs. Chris Sabin vs. Johnny Devine vs. Shark Boy (Escape From the Terror Dome) ***
Samoa Joe vs. Kaz vs. Scott Steiner ***1/4
5/15/08 Gail Kim vs. Awesome Kong ***1/4
5/29/08 Christian Cage vs. Tyson Tomko ***
6/5/2008 Kaz vs. Curry Man vs. Chris Sabin vs. Johnny Devine vs. Jimmy Rave (King of the Mountain) ***3/4
6/8/2008 Kaz vs. Petey Williams(X Title Match) ***1/2
6/8/2008 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
6/8/2008 Samoa Joe vs. Christian Cage vs. Rhino vs. Booker T vs. Robert Roode (King of the Mountain) ***1/2
6/12/08 Samoa Joe vs. Kaz ***1/4
6/12/08 Naruki Doi/Masato Yoshino vs. Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley ***1/2
6/19/08 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Daivari/Tyson Dux ***1/2
6/26/08 Ultimo Guerrero/Rey Bucanero vs. Naruki Doi/Masato Yoshino ***1/4
7/13/08 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin/Curry Man vs. Ultimo Guerrero/Rey Bucaner/Averno vs. Tyson Dux/Doug Williams/Alex Koslov vs. Masato Yoshino/Milano Collection A.T./Puma (Elimination) ****1/4
7/13/08 Kurt Angle/Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. AJ Styles/Christian Cage/Rhino (Full Metal Mayhem) ***3/4
7/13/08 Samoa Joe vs. Booker T ***
7/24/08 AJ Styles/Rhino/Christian Cage vs. Kurt Angle/Brother Ray/Brother Devon (Tables Elimination) ***1/4
8/10/08 Consequences Creed vs. Petey Williams ***1/4
8/10/08 Taylor Wilde/Gail Kim/ODB vs. Angelina Love/Velvet Sky/Awesome Kong ***
8/10/08 Homicide/Herandez vs. James Storm/Robert Roode ***1/2
8/10/08 Kurt Angle vs. AJ Styles (Last Man Standing) ****1/4
8/21/08 Gail Kim vs. Awesome Kong ***
8/21/08 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle (Ladder) ***
9/14/08 Jay Lethal vs. Sonjay Dutt (Ladder) ***1/2
9/14/08 Samoa Joe vs. Kurt Angle vs. Christian Cage ***1/4
10/12/07 Jay Lethal vs. Chris Sabin vs. Alex Shelly vs. Shark Boy vs. Curry Man vs. Super Eric vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Petey Williams vs. Johnny Devine vs. Jimmy Rave (Steel Asylum Match) ***1/4
10/12/08 Matt Morgan/Abyss vs. LAX vs. Team 3D vs. James Storm/Robert Roode (Moster's Ball) ***1/2
10/12/08 AJ Styles vs. Christian Cage vs. Booker T ***1/4
10/12/08 Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
10/12/08 Samoa Joe vs. Sting ***3/4
11/9/08 Eric Young vs. Consequences Creed vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Petey Williams vs. Jimmy Rave vs. Volador vs. Doug Williams vs. Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Homicide vs. Jay Lethal (Elimination) ***
11/9/08 Robert Roode /James Storm vs. Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin ***1/2
11/9/08 Kurt Angle vs. Abyss (Falls Count Anywhere) ****1/4
11/9/08 Kevin Nash vs. Samoa Joe ***1/2
11/9/08 Sting vs. AJ Styles ***1/4
12/7/08 Feast or Fired Battle Royal ***1/2
12/7/08 Kurt Angle vs. Rhino ***1/4
12/7/08 Sting/Scott Steiner/Kevin Nash/Booker T vs. AJ Styles/Samoa Joe/Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/2

2009

1/11/09 Alex Shelley vs. Chris Sabin ****
1/11/09 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett ****1/2
2/8/09 Alex Shelley vs. Eric Young ***1/4
3/15/09 Suicide vs. Jay Lethal vs. Consequences Creed vs. Chris Sabin vs. Alex Shelley (Ultimate X) ****
3/15/09 Kurt Angle vs. Sting ***1/4
4/16/09 Christopher Daniels vs. Kurt Angle ***1/2
4/19/09 Hernandez/Homicide vs. ALex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Yujiro/Tetsuya Naito (Cage) ***1/4

4/19/09 James Storm/Robert Roode vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon (Cage) ***1/2
4/19/09 Jeff Jarrett/AJ Styles/Samoa Joe/Christopher Daniels vs. Kurt Angle/Booker T/Kevin Nash/Scott Steiner (Lethal Lockdown) ***1/2
5/24/09 Jay Lethal/Eric Young/Consequences Creed vs. Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin/Sheik Abdul Bashir ***1/2
5/24/09 James Storm/Robert Roode vs. Doug Williams/Brutus Magnus ***1/2
5/24/09 AJ Styles vs. Booker T (I Quit) ***1/2
5/24/09 Sting vs. Jeff Jarrett vs. Mick Foley vs. Kurt Angle ***
6/21/09 Suicide vs. Jay Lethal vs. Alex Shelley vs. Chris Sabin vs. Consequences Creed (King of the Mountain) ***3/4
6/21/09 Abyss/Taylor Wilde vs. Raven/Daffney (Monsters Ball) ***1/4
6/21/09 Robert Roode/James Storm vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/4
6/21/09 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett vs. Samoa Joe vs. Mick Foley vs. AJ Styles (King of the Mountain) ***
8/16/09 Christopher Daniels vs. Suicide vs. Consequences Creed vs. Alex Shelley vs. Chris Sabin vs. Jay Lethal vs. Amazing Red vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero (Cage) ****
8/16/09 Samoa Joe vs. Homicide ***
8/16/09 Booker T/Scott Steiner vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon (Falls Count Anywhere, No DQ) ***
9/20/09 Samoa Joe vs. Daniels ***1/4
9/20/09 Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Suicide (Falls Count Anywhere) ***
9/20/09 Brother Ray/Brother Devon/Robert Roode/James Storm vs. Scott Steiner/Booker T/Brutus Magnus/Doug Williams (Lethal Lockdown) ***
9/20/09 Kurt Angle vs. AJ Styles vs. Matt Morgan vs. Sting vs. Hernandez ***
10/15/09 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4

10/18/09 Jay Lethal/Consequences Creed v Motor City Machine Guns (***)
10/18/09 Amazing Red v Daniels v Homicide v Suicide v Chris Sabin v Alex Shelley (Ultimate X) ***3/4
10/18/09 Team 3D v Beer Money v British Invasion v Booker T & Scott Steiner ***1/2
10/18/09 Bobby Lashley v Samoa Joe (Submission) ***1/4
10/18/09 Abyss v Mick Foley (Monster's Ball) ***1/4
10/18/09 Matt Morgan v Kurt Angle ****
10/18/09 Sting v AJ Styles ***1/4






























11/15/09 Amazing Red. vs Homicide ***1/4
11/15/09 Awesome Kong vs. Tara (Cage) ***1/4
11/15/09 Brother Ray/Brother Devon/Rhino vs. Hernandez/Matt Morgan/Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***
11/15/09 Kurt Angle vs. Desmond Wolfe ****1/4
11/15/09 AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe vs. Daniels ****1/2
12/20/09 Doug Williams/Brutus Magnus vs. Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley ***1/2
12/20/09 Kurt Angle vs. Desmond Wolfe (2 out of 3 falls, First Fall Pinfalls Only, Second Fall Submissions Only, Third Fall Escape the Cage) ****
12/20/09 AJ Styles vs. Daniels ****1/4 (Corrected by Dave Meltzer after initially writing ***1/4)

2010

1/4/10 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ****
1/17/10 Desmond Wolfe vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***
1/17/10 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ****
2/14/10 Mr. Anderson vs. Kurt Angle ***
2/14/10 AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe ***1/2
3/21/10 Kazarian vs. Brian Kendrick vs. Daniels vs. Amazing Red (Ladder) ***1/4
3/21/10 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Jeremy Buck/Max Buck (Ultimate X) ***3/4
4/18/10 Rob Van Dam vs. James Storm (Cage) ***
4/18/10 Kazarian vs. Shannon Moore vs. Homicide (Cage) ***1/2
4/18/10 Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. Scott Hall/Kevin Nash (Cage St. Louis Streetfight) ***
4/18/10 Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson (Cage) ****1/2
4/18/10 AJ Styles vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero (Cage) ***3/4
4/18/10 Abyss/Jeff Jarrett/Jeff Hardy/Rob Van Dam vs. Desmond Wolfe/Sting/James Storm/Robert Roode (Lethal Lockdown) ***1/4
4/19/10 AJ Styles vs. Rob Van Dam ***1/2
5/16/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon vs. Robert Roode/James Storm ***1/4
5/16/10 Rob Van Dam vs. AJ Styles ***1/2
6/13/10 Kurt Angle vs. Kazarian ****
6/13/10 Douglas Williams vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/2
6/13/10 Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson vs. James Storm/Robert Roode ***1/2
7/11/10 AJ Styles/Kazarian vs. Rob Terry/Samoa Joe ***
7/11/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode/James Storm ****
7/11/10 Kurt Angle vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***1/2
7/15/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode/James Storm (Ladder) ****
8/8/10 Rob Van Dam vs. Sabu ***
8/12/10 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
8/12/10 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. James Storm/Robert Roode (2 out of 3 Falls) ****1/2
8/12/10 Rob Van Dam vs. Abyss (Stairway to Janice) ***1/2
9/5/10 Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin vs. Max Buck/Jeremy Buck ***
9/5/10 Tommy Dreamer vs. AJ Styles (I Quit) ***1/2
9/5/10 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Hardy ****1/4
9/16/10 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Hardy ***1/2
10/10/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Max Buck/Jeremy Buck ****
10/10/10 Rob Van Dam vs. Abyss (Monster's Ball) ***1/4
10/10/10 Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson vs. Kurt Angle ****
11/7/10 Tara vs. Mickie James ***1/4
11/7/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Brother Ray/Brother Devon ***1/2
12/5/10 Robert Roode/James Storm vs. Shannon Moore/Jesse Neal ***1/4
12/5/10 Rob Van Dam vs. Rhino (First Blood) ***1/2
12/5/10 Doug Williams vs. AJ Styles ****
12/5/10 Chris Sabin/Alex Shelley vs. Max Buck/Jeremy Buck (Full Metal Mayhem) ***3/4

2011

1/9/11 Kazarian vs. Jay Lethal ***1/4
1/9/11 Robert Roode/James Storm vs. Alex Shelley/Chris Sabin ***3/4
1/9/11 Bully Ray vs. Brother Devon ***1/2
1/9/11 Mr. Anderson vs. Jeff Hardy ***1/2
2/13/11 Kazarian vs. Robbie E ***
2/13/11 Bully Ray vs. Brother Devon (Street Fight) ***1/2
2/13/11 Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4
2/13/11 Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson (Ladder) ***1/4
3/13/11 AJ Styles vs. Matt Hardy ***1/4
4/17/11 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett (2 out of 3 Falls) ****
4/17/11 Christopher Daniels/Robert Roode/James Storm/Kazarian vs. Ric Flair/Marr Hardy/Abyss/Bully Ray (Lethal Lockdown) ****
5/15/11 Kurt Angle/Chyna vs. Jeff Jarrett/Karen Jarrett ***
6/12/11 Alex Shelley/James Storm vs. Magnus/Douglas Williams ***
6/12/11 Bully Ray vs. AJ Styles (Last Man Standing) ****
6/12/11 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett ***3/4
7/10/11 Samoa Joe vs. Kazarian ***1/4
7/10/11 Alex Shelley vs. Shannon Moore vs. Robbie E vs. Amazing Red (Ultimate X) ***
7/10/11 Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn ***
7/10/11 Austin Aries vs. Low Ki vs. Zema Ion vs. Jack Evans ****
7/10/11 AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels ***3/4
8/7/11 AJ Styles vs. Frankie Kazarian/Christopher Daniels vs. Scott Steiner/Gunner/Abyss ***1/4
8/7/11 Bobby Roode/James Storm vs. Anarquia/Hernandez ***
8/7/11 Kurt Angle vs. Sting ***1/2
9/11/11 Bobby Roode vs. Gunner ***
9/11/11 Austin Aries vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/4
9/22/11 Kurt Angle vs. James Storm ***3/4
10/16/11 Austin Aries vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/2
10/16/11 Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn (Full Metal Mayhem) ***1/4
10/16/11 Mr. Anderson vs. Bully Ray (Falls Count Anywhere) ***1/2
10/16/11 Sting vs. Hulk Hogan ***
10/16/11 Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Roode ***
12/11/11 James Storm vs. Kurt Angle ***1/4
12/11/11 Jeff Hardy vs. Jeff Jarrett ***1/4
12/11/11 AJ Styles vs. Bobby Roode (30 Minute Iron Man) ***1/2

2012

1/8/12 Austin Aries vs. Jesse Soerensen vs. Kid Kash vs. Zema Ion ***
1/8/12 Devon vs. Pope ***
2/12/12 Austin Aries vs. Alex Shelley ***1/2
3/18/12 AJ Styles/Mr. Anderson vs. Kazarian/Christopher Daniels ***1/4
3/18/12 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Hardy ***3/4
3/18/12 Bobby Roode vs. Sting (No Holds Barred) ***1/4
4/15/12 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Hardy (Cage) ***3/4
4/15/12 Bobby Roode vs. James Storm (Cage) ***1/2
5/13/12 Kazarian/Christopher Daniels vs. Samoa Joe/Magnus ***1/4
5/13/12 Austin Aries vs. Bully Ray ***1/2
5/13/12 Kurt Angle vs. AJ Styles ****
5/13/12 Bobby Roode vs. Rob Van Dam (Ladder) ***3/4
5/24/12 Bobby Roode vs. AJ Styles ****1/4
6/10/12 Austin Aries vs. Samoa Joe ***3/4
 6/10/12 Mr. Anderson vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Rob Van Dam ***
6/10/12 Kurt Angle/AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels/Kazarian ****1/4
7/8/12 Kurt Angle vs. Samoa Joe ***3/4
7/8/12 Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles (Last Man Standing) ****1/4
7/8/12 Zema Ion vs. Sonjay Dutt vs. Kenny King vs. Mason Andrews (Ultimate X) ***1/4
7/8/12 Bobby Roode vs. Austin Aries ****1/2
8/9/12 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle "near ***3/4"
8/12/12  AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle vs. Christopher Daniels vs. Samoa Joe (Ladder) ***3/4
8/12/12 Austin Aries vs. Bobby Roode ****
8/30/12 Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Hardy ***1/2
9/6/12 Chavo Guerrero Jr./Hernandez vs. Christopher Daniels/Kazarian ***1/2
9/9/12 Zema Ion vs. Sonjay Dutt ***1/4
9/9/12 Christopher Daniels/Kazarian vs. AJ Styles/Kurt Angle ***3/4
10/14/12 James Storm vs. Bobby Roode (Street Fight) ***1/2
10/14/12 Christopher Daniels/Kazarian vs. Kurt Angle/AJ Styles vs. Chavo Guerrero Jr./Hernandez ****
10/14/12 Jeff Hardy vs. Austin Aries ****
10/25/12 Jeff Hardy vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
11/11/12 Samoe Joe vs. Magnus (No Disqualification) ***1/4
11/11/12 Chavo Guerrero Jr./Hernandez vs. Christopher Daniels/Kazarian ***
11/11/12 Jame Storm vs. AJ Styles vs. Bobby Roode ***1/2
11/11/12 Jeff Hardy vs. Austin Aries (Ladder) ****1/4
12/9/12  Austin Aries vs. Bully Ray ***1/4
12/9/12 Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles ***3/4
12/9/12 Jeff Hardy vs. Bobby Roode ***1/2

2013

1/13/13 Christopher Daniels vs. James Storm ***
1/13/13 Jeff Hardy vs. Austin Aries vs. Bobby Roode ****
3/10/13 Austin Aries/Bobby Roode vs. Chavo Guerrero Jr/Hernandez vs. Christopher Daniels/Kazarian ***1/4
3/10/13 Wes Brisco vs. Kurt Angle (Cage) ***
3/10/13 Samoa Joe/Eric Young/Sting/Magnus/James Storm vs. Garett Bischoff/Doc/Ken Anderson/Knox/Devon (Lethal Lockdown) ***1/4
3/10/13 Jeff Hardy vs. Bully Ray (Cage) ***
6/2/13 Chris Sabin vs. Kenny King vs. Suicide ***1/4
6/2/13 James Storm/Gunner vs. Chavo Guerrero Jr./Hernandez vs. Austin Aries/Bobby Roode vs. Daniels/Kazarian (Elimination) ***1/4
6/2/13 Taryn Terrell vs. Gail Kim (Last Knockout Standing) ***1/2
6/2/13 Kurt Angle vs. AJ Styles ****
6/2/13 Bully Ray vs. Sting ***
8/1/13 Austin Aries vs. AJ Styles ****
9/12/13 AJ Styles vs. Austin Aries ***3/4
9/12/13 Magnus vs. Bobby Roode ***1/4
9/12/13 Bully Ray vs. Ken Anderson ***1/2
9/12/13 AJ Styles vs. Magnus ***3/4
10/10/13 Austin Aries vs. Jeff Hardy ***3/4
10/20/13 Chris Sabin vs. Samoa Joe vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Manik vs. Austin Aries (Ultimate X) ***
 10/20/13  Bobby Roode vs. Kurt Angle ***3/4
10/20/13 AJ Styles vs. Bully Ray (No DQ) ***1/2
10/31/13 Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Roode ****
11/14/13 Kurt Angle vs. Austin Aries (Submission Match) ***1/4

2014

1/23/14 Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Roode (Cage) ***3/4
3/9/14 Great Muta/Sanada/Yasu vs. Christopher Daniels/Frankie Kazarian/Chris Sabin ***1/4
3/9/14 Gunner vs. James Storm (Last Man Standing) (Cage) ***1/4
3/9/14 Madison Rayne vs. Gail Kim (Cage) ***
3/27/14 Gunner vs. James Storm ***3/4
4/10/14 Eric Young vs. Magnus ***
4/27/14 Gunner vs. James Storm (I Quit) ***1/2
4/27/14 Eric Young vs. Magnus
6/15/14 Seiya Senada vs. Crazzy Steve vs. Eddie Edwards vs. Davey Richards vs. Tiger Uno vs. Manik (Ladder) ***3/4
6/15/14 Bobby Lashley vs. Samoa Joe ***
6/15/14  Austin Aries vs. Kenny King ***1/4
6/15/14 Ethan Carter III vs. Bully Ray (Texas Death Match) ***1/4
6/15/14 Eric Young vs. Bobby Lashley vs. Austin Aries ***1/2
7/31/14 Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards vs. Matt Hardy/Jeff Hardy ****
7/31/14 Bobby Lashley vs. Austin Aries ***3/4
9/10/14 Matt Hardy/Jeff Hardy vs. Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards vs. Bully Ray/Devon (Tables) ***3/4
10/9/14 Matt Hardy/Jeff Hardy vs. Bully Ray/Devon vs. Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards (TLC) ****1/2
10/12/14 Minoru Tanaka vs. Manik ***1/4
10/12/14 Samoa Joe vs. Low Ki vs. Kaz Hayashi ***3/4
10/12/14 Jiro Kuroshio/Yusuke Kodama vs. Andy Woo/El Hijo del Pantera ***1/4
10/14/14 Bobby Roode vs. Austin Aries vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Eric Young ***3/4
10/29/14 Bobby Roode vs. Bobby Lashley ***1/2

2015

3/13/15 Bobby Roode vs. Eric Young (Last Man Standing) ***1/2
3/13/15 Ethan Carter III vs. Spud (Hair vs. Hair) ***3/4
3/18/15 Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards vs/ Manik/Sanada vs. Jessie Godders/DJ Zema Ion (Ultimate X) "Hovering at the **** level"
3/18/15 Awesome Kong vs. Taryn Terrell vs. Gail Kim ***1/4
3/18/15 Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Lashley ****1/4
4/10/15 Kurt Angle vs. Eric Young vs. Bobby Lashley "***1/2 level"
5/29/15 Kurt Angle vs. Eric Young (I Quit) "Probably ***3/4 level"
6/10/15 Kurt Angle vs. Austin Aries ****
7/1/15 Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards vs. Austin Aries/Bobby Roode (Iron Man) ****
7/1/15 Kurt Angle vs. EC3 ****
10/4/15 Tiger Uno vs. DJ Zema Ion vs. Manik vs. Andrew Everett (Ultimate X) ***1/2
10/4/15 Eddie Edwards/Davey Richards vs. Brian Myers/Trevor Lee ***1/2
10/4/15 Kurt Angle vs. Eric Young ***
10/4/15 Matt Hardy vs. EC3 vs. Drew Galloway ***



257 comments:

  1. How long does it usually take for him to rate the matches, basically when will we find out here how many stars he gave Angle vs. Styles from iMPACT! this week.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  3. He reviews everything the week it airs. I think this site is updated about once a month though.

    He doesn't rate every single TV so he may not give Angle/Styles a rating.

    ReplyDelete
  4. He gave Angle/AJ from last week ****1/4

    BFG ratings
    Motor City machine guns/lethal consequences ***
    Ultimate X ***3/4
    KO's tag titles *1/2
    Eric Young/Hernandez/Lashley *
    Full Metal Mayhem ***1/2
    Tara/ODB/Kong **3/4
    Lashley/Joe ***1/4
    Abyss/Foley ***1/4
    Kurt Angle/Matt Morgan ****
    Sting/AJ ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  5. Can't believe he rated Abyss/Foley so highly.The match was awful!
    The ref botch sunk it ever further.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Interested to see his ratings for Angle-Wolfe and Joe-Daniels-AJ.

    I thought Angle vs. Wolfe was ****1/4
    Joe vs. AJ vs. Daniels was ****1/2

    ReplyDelete
  7. I say Angle VS Wolfe ****1/2
    Joe VS Daniels Vs AJ was ****3/4

    ReplyDelete
  8. Joe/Daniels/Styles should hopefully get the full boat.

    Angle/Wolfe was about **** for me, maybe ****1/4

    ReplyDelete
  9. if HBK vs Taker did not get the full boat this should no too

    ReplyDelete
  10. HBK vs Taker wasn't intresting cause everybody knew the Winner...

    ReplyDelete
  11. does anybody have turning point ratings

    ReplyDelete
  12. I have yet to understand how "knowing" the result of a match makes it some less good.

    Anyways. TURNING POINT~!!!

    First this show got a 100% thumbs up from the readers. I have no idea what the last WWE or TNA show that got the perfect percentage from the readers was but it's easily been a year or greatly more. The only wrestling show this year that has was the second DGUSA show (I know that in terms of MMA UFC 102, TUF 9, and Fight Night: Diaz/Guillard all did and I might be missing one or two more).

    RATINGS!

    Amazing Red/Homicide ***1/4
    ODB, Wilde and Sarita/Velvet, Madison and Lacey Von Erich *3/4
    British Invasion/Beer Money/MTMG **1/2
    Tara/Awesome Kong ***1/4
    Team 3-D and Rhino/Hernandez, Morgan and Pope ***
    Steiner/Lasley *
    Angle/Wolfe ****1/4
    Styles/Joe/Daniels ****1/2

    ReplyDelete
  13. I think Backlash this year also had 100% thumbs up from the readers...

    Nonetheless, this PPV was really good and had 2 potential MOTYC in many people's minds.

    Those 2 matches, IMO, are a must-see for any TNA or non-TNA fan

    ReplyDelete
  14. Backlash had a 91.7% thumps up. I thought of this show too when I was trying to remember the last WWE/TNA show that got the full 100%.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Oh.. ok. Thanks for the information!

    ReplyDelete
  16. -amazing red vs homicide ***1/2
    -odb,sarita,and taylor wilde vd lacey von erich,velvet sky, and madison rayne *1/4
    -doug williams and brutus magnus vs chris sabin and alex shelley vs james storm and robert roode ***1/2
    -tara vs awesome kong ***3/4
    -brother ray,brother devon,and rhino vs matt morgan,hernadezand, d'angelo dinero ***1/4
    -scott steiner vs bobby lashley *1/2
    -kurt angle vs desmond wolfe ****1/4
    -aj styles vs somoa joe vs daniels ****3/4

    ReplyDelete
  17. Any word on Final Resolution ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  18. Just got done reading this week's Observer so here you go:

    British Invasion vs. MCMG ***1/2
    Tara vs. ODB *
    Feast or Fired *
    Morgan/Hernandez/Pope/Suicide vs. Team 3-D/Rhino/Jesse Neal *1/2 (and the rant about the chair shot is one of the best things Meltzer's written all year)
    Lashley vs. Steiner **1/4
    Foley/Abyss vs. Raven/Stevie **3/4
    Angle/Wolfe ****
    Styles/Daniels ***1/4

    The show got 100% thumbs up from the readers as well for the second straight month for TNA.

    ReplyDelete
  19. What the hell? That rating for AJ/Daniels can't be right.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I agree with that rating, AJ & Daniels just didn't click for me, I didn't enjoy it as much as Angle/Wolfe.

    Why was there a rant about the chair shot?

    ReplyDelete
  21. The Styles/Daniels rating was actually ****1/4. A correction was posted today.

    As far as the chair goes, it's because it's mindblowing stupid to be doing unprotected chair shots to the head in nearly 2010 when we know all that we do about concussions. It meant nothing outside of a huge pop that was probably forgotten by 90% of the audience half an later.

    ReplyDelete
  22. Styles/Joe/Daniels from Turning Point should've gotten 5 stars... Screw Meltzer.

    ReplyDelete
  23. Dean said...

    Styles/Joe/Daniels from Turning Point should've gotten 5 stars... Screw Meltzer.
    December 31, 2009 5:44 PM

    IF that match got 5 then Taker VS Shawn should have goton 6 stars

    ReplyDelete
  24. And Misawa/Kobashi vs. Kawada/Taue match from Summer '95 should have gotten 17 stars.

    It's a vicious circle.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Any word about Aj vs Angle in the last Impact rating?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Bryan Alvarez gave it ***3/4
    Wade Keller gave it ****1/4
    J.D. Dunn it ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  27. Meltzer's ratings for Genesis?

    ReplyDelete
  28. Amazing Red vs. Brian Kendrick **1/2
    Sean Morley vs. Daniels *1/2
    Tara vs. ODB *
    Matt Morgan & Hernandez vs. Doug Williams & Brutus Magnus **
    Desomond Wolfe vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***
    Beer Money vs. Kevin Nash & Sean Waltman *3/4
    Mr. Anderson vs. Abyss *1/4
    AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ****

    ReplyDelete
  29. Did you updated past ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  30. Just read them:

    Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Desmond Wolfe **3/4
    Matt Morgan vs. Hernandez **
    Mr. Anderson vs. Kurt Angle ***
    Abyss vs. Mick Foley *
    The Nasty Boys vs. Team 3-D *
    Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Matt Morgan *1/2
    Mr. Anderson vs. Abyss *1/4
    AJ Styles vs. Samoa Joe ***1/2
    Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Mr. Anderson **1/2

    ReplyDelete
  31. Wow only ***1/2 for Styles-Joe? That's surprising, I had it rated at atleast ****.

    Also kind of shocked Dinero-Anderson didn't atleast crack ***.

    ReplyDelete
  32. DX 2010
    Ladder Match ***1/4
    Tara/Daffney 1/4*
    Terry/Magnus DUD
    UX ***3/4
    Band/EY & Nash *
    Williams/Moore *3/4
    Tag Title *1/2
    Angle/Kennedy **1/2
    AJ/Abyss **

    ReplyDelete
  33. Ratings for Lockdown? Really curious to see what Meltzer gave Anderson-Angle. Match of the year thus far IMO.

    ReplyDelete
  34. have Alvarez and Meltzer rated the show yet

    ReplyDelete
  35. Bryan:

    Rob Van Damn vs. James Storm ***1/4
    Motor City Machine Guns vs. Homicide & Brian Kendrick (Xscape the Cage) **1/4
    Kevin Nash vs. Eric Young *
    Madison Rayne & Velvet Sky vs. Tara & Angelina Love 1/2*
    Homicide vs. Kazarian vs. Shannon Moore *1/4
    Kevin Nash & Scott Hall vs. Team 3-D (Falls Count Anywhere, Street Fight CAGE MATCH) **1/4
    Mr. Anderson vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4
    AJ Styles vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***3/4
    Abyss, Jeff Jarrett, Jeff Hardy & Rob Vanm vs. Sting, Robert Roode, James Storm & Desmond Wolfe (Lethal Lockdown) *1/2

    Meltzer:
    Rob Van Dam vs. James Storm ***
    Homicide vs. Chris Sabin vs. Alex Shelley vs. Brian Kendrick (Xscape the Cage) *3/4
    Kevin Nash vs. Eric Young *1/4
    Velvet Sky & Madison Rayne vs. Tara & ODB 1/2*
    Kazarian vs. Shannon Moore vs. Homicide ***1/2
    Team 3-D vs. Kevin Nash & Scott (Falls Count Anywhere CAGE MATCH) ***
    Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson ****1/2
    AJ Styles vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***3/4
    Abyss, Jeff Jarrett, Jeff Hardy & Rob Van Dam vs. Sting, Desmond Wolfe, Robert Roode & James Storm (Lethal Lockdown) ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  36. did meltzer rate any of the tv matches from monday?

    ReplyDelete
  37. Yeah he gave both RVD vs. Hardy and RVD vs. Styles a ***1/2 rating.

    ReplyDelete
  38. Did Dave or Bryan rate the ladder match between Angle and Anderson?

    ReplyDelete
  39. Nope. Bryan, like me, was too busy trying to figure out who would put KURT ANGLE AND KEN ANDERSON in a ladder match. Recipe for disaster.

    ReplyDelete
  40. Rating for Sacrifice?

    ReplyDelete
  41. Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode & James Storm vs. Team 3-D ***1/4
    Rob Terry vs. Orlando Jordan DUD
    Doug Williams vs. Kazarian *3/4
    Madison Rayne vs. Tara DUD
    Kevin Nash & Scott Hall vs. Jesse Neal & Shannon Moore 1/4*
    Abyss vs. Desmond Wolfe *3/4
    Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson **3/4
    Sting vs. Jeff Jarrett NR
    Rob Van Dam vs. AJ Styles ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  42. Wow. I felt that kazarian vs Doug was at least ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  43. Meltzer has become way too harsh on TNA. RVD vs. Styles only got ***1/2 stars? That's the same rating he gave to the match RVD won the title in, which wasn't half as good and was barely ten minutes long. Jeff Hardy vs. Anderson was definitely worth ***, and the rating he gave to Kaz and Williams is unforgivable, they had a damn good match, like the commenter above me said, atleast ***1/2 stars.

    ReplyDelete
  44. Sure the TV match was shorter than the PPV one but the PPV also had the first 1/5th of so being total stalling. Match times tell so very little of the story.

    Bryan gave the same rating to RVD/Styles (and did go *** on Kazarian/Williams). So it's not like no one else came up with the same thing.

    Then again, I'll probably defend any ratings because I hate that miserable company.

    ReplyDelete
  45. Ratings for Slammiversary?

    ReplyDelete
  46. Observer won't be out until Thursday or Friday of this week but here's Bryan's:

    Slammiversary
    Kurt Angle vs. Kazarian ***1/4
    Doug Williams vs. Brian Kendrick ***
    Madison Rayne vs. Roxxi **
    Bubba Ray vs. Jesse Neal *1/2
    Matt Morgan vs. Hernandez *
    Desmond Wolfe vs. Abyss (Monster's Ball Match) *
    AJ Styles vs. Jay Lethal ***1/2
    Beer Money vs. Jeff Hardy & Mr. Anderson ***1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Sting *3/4

    ReplyDelete
  47. And Meltzer's:

    Kurt Angle vs. Kazarian ****
    Doug Williams vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/2
    Madison Rayne vs. Roxxi *3/4
    Jesse Neal vs. Brother Ray 3/4*
    Matt Morgan vs. Hernandez 1/2*
    Abyss vs. Desmond Wolfe (Monster's Ball Match) DUD
    Jay Lethal vs. AJ Styles ***1/2
    Jeff Hardy & Mr. Anderson vs. Robert Roode & James Storm ***1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Sting *1/4

    ReplyDelete
  48. victory road up?

    ReplyDelete
  49. Meltzer:
    Doug Williams vs. Brian Kendrick (Ultimate X & Submission Match) **
    Brother Ray vs. Brother Devon vs. Jesse Neal *
    Madison Rayne vs. Angelina Love 1/4*
    AJ Styles & Kazarian vs. Rob Terry & Samoa Joe ***
    Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan (Cage Match) *3/4
    Jay Lethal vs. Ric Flair **3/4
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode & James Storm ****
    Kurt Angle vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero ***1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Abyss vs. Mr. Anderson **

    Bryan:
    Doug Williams vs. Brian Kendrick (Ultimate X & Submission Match) **1/4
    Brother Ray vs. Jesse Neal vs. Brother Devon *1/2
    Madison Rayne vs. Angelina Love -*
    AJ Styles vs. Kazarian vs. Rob Terry & Samoa JOe **1/2
    Matt Morgan vs. Hernandez (Cage Match) *3/4
    Ric Flair vs. Jay Lethal ***
    The Motor City Machine Guns vs. Beer Money ****
    Kurt Angle vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero ***1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Mr. Anderson vs. Jeff Hardy vs. Abyss **

    ReplyDelete
  50. I don't agree with the ratings :-)
    For me :

    Williams vs Kendrick : **3/4
    D Von vs Ray vs Neal : *3/4
    Rayne vs Love : *
    AJ Styles/Kaz vs Joe/Terry : ***1/4
    Hernandez vs Morgan : **1/4
    Flair vs Lethal : ***1/4
    MCMG vs Beer Money : ****1/4
    Angle vs Dinero : **3/4
    RVD vs Hardy vs Abyss vs Anderson : ***1/2

    This is mine :-)

    ReplyDelete
  51. Who gives a fuck i can put **** and be more credible than that cunt Meltzer!!!

    ReplyDelete
  52. Yeah, but I like to compare what I think with Melzer cause he is one of the few ( Is it correct???) to rate matchs.

    ReplyDelete
  53. Did he rate the ladder match from last week or Joe/RVD?

    ReplyDelete
  54. Meltzer on the Beer Money/MCMG ladder match on 7/15:

    "every bit of a **** match, even better than the PPV match."

    ReplyDelete
  55. Has Meltzer rated any other matches from the Best of 5 Series w/ MCMG & Beer Money?

    ReplyDelete
  56. do u have to subscribe to know meltzer's thoughts on matches? (eg: his thoughts on the beer money/MCMG ladder match). Is there any other way of finding out his thoughts on these matches?

    ReplyDelete
  57. Anonymous #1: No other ratings.

    Anonymous #2: Yes. He doesn't do any other columns or reviews except what's in the newsletter. It's easily worth the $10 a month for the newsletter and the Karl Stern radio show. If anything, find some friends who also interested in subscribing and just split the cost and share the username/password. I'm surprised more people don't do the latter.

    ReplyDelete
  58. Have Alvarez or Meltzer commented on HardCORE Justice yet?

    ReplyDelete
  59. Observer doesn't come out until Wednesday or Thursday but here's Bryan's:

    Hardcore Justice
    Guido Maritato, Tracy Smothers & Tony Luke vs. Kid Kash & Simon Diamond & Johnny Swinger **
    Too Cold Scorpio vs. C.W. Anderson *1/2
    Stevie Richards vs. P.J. Polaco **1/2
    Al Snow vs. Brother Runt vs. Rhino (Elimination) **1/2
    Axl Rotten & Kahoneys vs. Team 3-D **3/4
    Tommy Dreamer vs. Raven *3/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Sabu **1/4

    ReplyDelete
  60. And Meltzer's:

    Hardcore Justice
    Tracy Smothers, Guido Maritato & Tony Luke vs. Kid Kash, Johnny Swinger & Simon Diamond *
    Too Cold Scorpio vs. C.W. Anderson *1/2
    Stevie Richards vs. P.J. Polaco *1/2
    Rhino vs. Brother Runt vs. Al Snow (Elimination Match) **
    Team 3-D vs. Axl Rotten & Kahones *1/2
    Raven vs. Tommy Dreamer *1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Sabu ***

    ReplyDelete
  61. Any ratings for The Whole F´n Show yet?

    ReplyDelete
  62. If he rates the show it won't be until mid-next week when the new issue comes out.

    ReplyDelete
  63. Meltzer is a bitch ass pussy a disgrace to any sort of physical activity.

    ReplyDelete
  64. No rating for the UX or cage match? That's a shame.

    Nothing for The Whole Fn Show either?

    ReplyDelete
  65. The Whole FN Show aired the same day the last issue came out which is why there was no ratings earlier.

    He didn't rate everything on the show but here's what he did:

    Kurt Angle vs. AJ Styles ***3/4
    Jeff Hardy vs. Shannon Moore **1/2
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode & James Storm (2/3 Falls Match) ****1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Abyss (Stairway to Janice Match) ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  66. Meltzer should rate the 5 matches of the series...It was awesome. To me the best feud of the year.

    ReplyDelete
  67. 6/13/10 Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson vs. James Storm/Robert Roode was actually ***1/4.

    ReplyDelete
  68. In my opinion, Hardy/Anderson vs Beer Money is a ****

    ReplyDelete
  69. This list is missing Jay Lethal vs. AJ Styles from Slammiversary which was ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  70. Meltzer's No Surrender ratings

    Guns/G-me ***

    Williams/Sabu **1/4

    Velvet/Madison DUD

    Abyss/Rhino **

    Wolfpack vs JJ/Joe = **

    AJ/Dreamer: ***1/2

    Kurt Angle vs Jeff Hardy ****1/4

    Pope/Anderson *3/4

    ReplyDelete
  71. Jeff Hardy vs. Kurt Angle from the 9/16 TV was given ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  72. Anyone knows the ratings for BFG???
    And please. Someone can post the thoughts of Meltzer about the heel turn of Jeff Hardy?

    ReplyDelete
  73. Meltzer:
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Jeremy & Max Buck ****
    Angelina Love vs. Madison Rayne vs. Tara vs. Velvet Sky 1/2*
    Shannon Moore & Jesse Neal vs. Orlando Jordan & Eric Young **
    Jay Lethal vs. Doug Williams **3/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Abyss (Monster's Ball Match) ***1/4
    Sting, Kevin Nash & Pope D' Angelo Dinero vs. Samoa Joe & Jeff Jarrett *3/4
    Tommy Dreamer, Rhino, Stevie Richards, Raven & Sabu vs. AJ Styles, Robert Roode, James Storm, Kazarian & Matt Morgan (Lethal Lockdown) **1/2
    Jeff Hardy vs. Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson (No DQ Match) ****

    Bryan:
    Bound for Glory
    The Motor City Machine Guns vs. Generation Me ****
    Angelina Love vs. Madison Rayne vs. Tara vs. Velvet Sky DUD
    Ink INc vs. Eric Young & Orlando Jordan -*
    Jay Lethal vs. Doug Williams ***
    Abyss vs. Rob Van Dam (Monster's Ball) ***1/2
    Kevin Nash, Sting & Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Jeff Jarrett & Samoa Joe *1/2
    AJ Styles, Kazarian, Beer Money & Matt Morgan vs. Tommy Dreamer, Stevie Richards, Raven, Sabu & Rhino *1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson vs. Jeff Hardy (No DQ) ***1/2

    As to his thoughts on the Hardy heel turn he basically said that while it's a risky move to turn the biggest babyface in the company (and who was the biggest star in the business last year), it's not the risk people think it is (like Goldberg and Austin turns). Also pointed that he (and no one has else) has meant anything for PPV since the only show to do improved numbers this year was Hardcore Justice and actually buyrates across the board are LOWER since he came on board so some of the concern over negative effect on "business" isn't really the case either. He is the biggest star on house shows but the people who come to their house shows tend to make people who they like into faces regardless of how they're booked.

    ReplyDelete
  74. AJ Styles vs. Jay Lethal from Slammiversary needs to be added to the full list.

    ReplyDelete
  75. Did he rate Flair-Foley from the live Impact?

    ReplyDelete
  76. Looking forward to the ratings for Turning Point, mainly because of how godawful the show was. I'd be surprised if anything other than the 3D-MCMG match hit ***.

    ReplyDelete
  77. where is the ratings of turning point?

    ReplyDelete
  78. Observer ratings are never available before Wednesday night.

    Here's Bryan's though:

    Turning Point
    Jay Lethal vs. Robbie E. **3/4
    Tara vs. Mickie James ***1/4
    The Motor City Machine Guns vs. Team 3-D ***3/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Tommy Dreamer *1/2
    Kazarian, AJ Styles, Beer Money, Doug Williams vs. Rhino, Sabu, Stevie Richards, Raven & Brian Kendrick **1/2
    Abyss vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero (Lumberjack Match) DUD
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Samoa Joe DUD
    Jeff Hardy vs. Matt Morgan *

    ReplyDelete
  79. Before the ratings, this is the best thing ever.

    Bryan's cat watching MCMG vs. Team 3-D: http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs889.snc4/72240_10150305275165624_851810623_15937960_5233528_n.jpg

    Bryan's cat watching RVD vs. Dreamer: http://sphotos.ak.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ak-snc4/hs997.snc4/77000_10150307401465624_851810623_15968900_3515196_n.jpg

    Hopefully the cat starts rating soon.

    Anyway, here's Meltzer's:

    Jay Lethal vs. Robbie E. **3/4
    Tara vs. Mickie James ***1/4
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Team 3-D ***1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Tommy Dreamer *1/2
    Kazarian, AJ Styles, Robert Roode, James Storm & Doug Williams vs. Brian Kendrick, Stevie Richards, Raven, Rhino & Sabu **1/4
    Abyss vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero (Lumberjack Match) *1/4
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Samoa Joe *1/2
    Jeff Hardy vs. Matt Morgan *1/2

    NOTE: This show did a 100% thumbs down in the Observer poll. I never recall a show doing that bad. There have been worse shows that probably got a thumbs in the middle just due to being so bad it became funny. Not this show apparently.

    ReplyDelete
  80. Dave Meltzer very, but very underrates big part of TNA matches. BTW, where's
    Angle-Anderson from Dest.X,
    AJ-Lethal from Slammy,
    BMI-MCMG Ultimate X,
    Abyss-Wolfe both matches,
    Raven-Dreamer,
    Lethal-Flair,
    Pope-Wolfe AAO,
    Anderson-Hardy Sacrifice,
    Kaz-Moore,
    RVD-Joe,
    Hardy-Joe,
    Foley-Flair,
    Abyss-Angle Cage?

    Those matches were at least ***, and some of them even higher. Put those matches on your list Meltzer!

    ReplyDelete
  81. He almost never rates TV matches so any argument there is out. In terms of PPV, it's just subjective.

    ReplyDelete
  82. Can't believe both he and Bryan gave Tara vs. Mickie ***1/4. That was your average knockouts match at best.

    ReplyDelete
  83. The average Knockouts match is garbage. I'm not saying it was ***1/4 but to say it wasn't significantly between than most is insane.

    ReplyDelete
  84. Ratings for Final Resolution?FR was a great PPV... in the first half...

    ReplyDelete
  85. Meltzer:
    Robert Roode & James Storm vs. Shannon Moore & Jesse Neal ***1/4
    Tara vs. Mickie James (Falls Count Anywhere Match) **1/2
    Robbie E. vs. Jay Lethal **1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Rhino (First Blood Match) ***1/2
    AJ Styles vs. Doug Williams ****
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Generation Me (Full Metal Mayhem Match) ***3/4
    Abyss vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero (Casket Match) **
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Samoa Joe (Submission Match) *1/2
    Jeff Hardy vs. Matt Morgan (No DQ Match) *1/2

    Bryan:
    Beer Money vs. Ink Inc ***1/2
    Tara vs. Mickie James (Falls Count Anywhere) ***
    Robbie E. vs. Jay Lethal **1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Rhino (First Blood) ***1/2
    AJ Styles vs. Doug Williams ****
    Motor City Machine Guns vs. Generation Me (Full Metal Mayhem) ***3/4
    Abyss vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero (Casket Match) *
    Samoa Joe vs. Jeff Jarrett (Submission) NR?
    Jeff Hardy vs. Matt Morgan (No DQ) NR?

    ReplyDelete
  86. very good PPV, 3 matchs have *** or more and one can get ****, but in my opinion MCMG vs Young Bucks can get a ****

    ReplyDelete
  87. I thought MCMG-Generation Me was a phenomenal match. I seem to be in the minority, but it's on my list of the best matches of 2010.

    Meltzer is far too generous giving Joe-Jarrett *1/2. If any match this year deserved minus five stars, it was this godawful piece of garbage masquerading as a co-main event.

    ReplyDelete
  88. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  89. Man, Douglas Wiliams vs Aj Stiles iron man is a awesome match, in my opinion Meltzer can give a **** for this match

    ReplyDelete
  90. ANGLE IS THE BEST EVERֱֱֱ

    ReplyDelete
  91. Does Meltzer made any comments on the James vs. Tara Cage match on impact?

    ReplyDelete
  92. Meltzer on the cage match (no rating but here's the note from the review):

    "The two worked hard. I don’t think it was as good as their first PPV match, but the finish, which was James coming off the top of the high cage with a Thesz press on Tara, for the pin, was spectacular."

    ReplyDelete
  93. Meltzer comment about Aj Stiles vs Douglas Wiliams IronMan?

    ReplyDelete
  94. Any ratings of Genesis and the Iron Man between Aj and Doug?

    ReplyDelete
  95. No rating on Styles/Williams Iron Man but the following was the only comment on it: "Good match, although not quite the level of their PPV match."

    No ratings from Meltzer for Genesis yet but here's Bryan's:
    Genesis 2010
    Jay Lethal vs. Kazarian ***1/4
    Madison Rayne vs. Mickie James *3/4
    The Motor City Machine Guns vs. Beer Money ***3/4
    Bully Ray vs. Brother Devon **3/4
    Doug Williams vs. Abyss **
    Rob Van Dam vs. Matt Hardy *
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle (MMA Exhibition) NR
    Matt Morgan vs. Mr. Anderson *1/2
    Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  96. And here's Meltzer's Genesis reatings:
    Jay Lethal vs. Kazarian ***1/4
    Madison Rayne vs. Mickie James *
    Chris Sabin & Alex Shelley vs. Robert Roode & James Storm ***3/4
    Bully Ray vs. Brother Devon ***1/2
    Doug Williams vs. Abyss *1/4
    Matt Hardy vs. Rob Van Dam *1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett (MMA Exhibition) *1/2
    Mr. Anderson vs. Matt Morgan **1/2
    Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  97. LOL they both gave Hardy vs. Anderson ***1/2? What match were they watching? That was a TERRIBLE match, Hardy has never looked more sluggish and unmotivated in the ring and he was constantly no-selling Anderson's offense to the point where it was clearly hurting the match. Throw in a terrible finish and we have a candidate for worst main event of 2011 so far.

    I don't understand what the hell they saw in that match.

    I thought Matt Hardy vs. RVD was much better than the ratings they gave it as well. Certainly much better than the main event was.

    ReplyDelete
  98. The show was on the 9th of January. Are we seriously going to say "OMG~! WORST FINISH OF 2011 SO FAR~!"?

    I don't agree with the rating either (to the point that I'd almost drop an entire star off it) but if you're putting a lot of emphasis on how it gets over to the crowd, I could see going ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  99. How did he comment Hardy vs Anderson?
    Maybe he justified well the rating he gave to this match?
    If you can I want also the comments about ray vs devon & MCMG vs Beer Money
    Thank's in advance

    ReplyDelete
  100. ***1/2 is for the drama

    ReplyDelete
  101. Comments (I'm keeping these short because I'm not going to copy and paste sizeable portions of the Observer and plus the grand majority is just play by play recaps):

    Anderson/Hardy - Overbooked but the crowd actually got hot for the match as it went on. Basically a chunk of that rating was for the heat (which personally I think was as much due to the shock of that match being made than anything in the match itself)

    Beer $$$/MCMG - Best match on the show but nowhere close to the level of their TV match in August (I assume he means the 2/3 Falls match which was one of the best TV matches all year) and felt like far more of a traditional tag match.

    Ray/Devon - Brawl with a ton of heat which was basically what the first match of this program should have been.

    ReplyDelete
  102. Thank's a ton I personally think that he overrates Hardy/Anderson a little (the crowd can heat a match but can't made it far better than he is)but he has at least good arguments.

    ReplyDelete
  103. any comments to TNA Against all Odds?

    ReplyDelete
  104. Ratings for Against All Odds? JJ vs Angle should receive 4*..

    ReplyDelete
  105. No match involving custody stipulations can get four stars in my book.

    The Observer isn't out until tomorrow evening but here's Bryan's:

    Kazarian vs. Robbie E ***1/4
    Beer Money & Scott Steiner vs. Rob Terry, Gunner & Murphy **3/4
    Samoa Joe vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero *3/4
    Madison Rayne vs. Mickie James (Last Knockout Standing Match) 1/2*
    Matt Hardy vs. Rob Van Dam **1/2
    Bully Ray vs. Brother Devon (Street Fight) NR? (likely just an oversight)
    Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett ***3/4
    Mr. Anderson vs. Jeff Hardy (Ladder Match) **3/4

    ReplyDelete
  106. And Meltzer's Against All Odds ratings:

    Kazarian vs. Robbie E ***
    Scott Steiner, Robert Roode & James Storm vs. Rob Terry, Gunner & Murphy **3/4
    Samoa Joe vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero **1/4
    Madison Rayne vs. Mickie James (Last Knockout Standing Match) **1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Matt Hardy **3/4
    Bull Ray vs. Brother Devon (Street Fight) ***1/2
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4
    Jeff Hardy vs. Mr. Anderson (Ladder Match) ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  107. Good god, Meltzer gave that Ray-Devon "match" ***1/2 stars? That was just painful to watch it was so bad. He also really, really overrated Jarrett-Angle I'd say. I also thought the opener wasn't worth ***, but I can see why someone might like it. Robbie E totally sucked the life out of that match I thought though.

    Bizarre ratings.

    ReplyDelete
  108. I can't wait to see Victory Road ratings.
    The show was fine and solid until the main event in my opinion. WTF happened there!?

    Best match: AJ-Matt and Ultimate X.

    ReplyDelete
  109. Bryan's ratings (and this was maybe the funniest review of a PPV I've ever read including ONE THOUSAND words on that abortion of a main event):

    Victory Road
    Bully Ray vs. Tommy Dreamer *3/4
    Angelina Love & Winter vs. Sarita & Rosita -***
    Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan (First Blood Match) -*
    Jeremy Buck vs. Max Buck vs. Kazarian vs. Robbie E (Ultimate X Match) **3/4
    Beer Money vs. Ink Inc ***
    AJ Styles vs. Matt Hardy ***1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Mr. Anderson NR? "Another negative star match."
    Sting vs. Jeff Hardy -*****

    ReplyDelete
  110. Now I want to see what he wrote about the main event xD (aside the obvious things)

    ReplyDelete
  111. And where are Meltzer's ratings?
    Gee, these are so unreal ratings.
    Ult. X only **3/4? Give me a frickin break!

    ReplyDelete
  112. Sting vs. Jeff Hardy for the TNA Title. Hardy wobbled down to the ring all unsteady, tripping on the ring steps on the way in. They did the fancy ring introductions, then Eric Bischoff came out and said there had been a change in plans. He said they'd had a situation on March 3rd where the Network got involved in their business. Bischoff went on and on and on and wouldn't just spit out what he was trying to say. Long story short, this match is no-DQ. Sting punched him right in the face. Bischoff made a funny sound when he got punched. That was the only redeeming thing about this. Jeff took off his shirt and started walking around the ring teasing that he'd throw the shirt into the crowd. Then he just dropped it. What a meanie. So they locked up, then Sting punched him, hooked him in the death drop and pinned him. Match, and this is including the t-shirt bullshit, went 1 minute and 29 seconds. They showed a replay and they tried to pretend that Jeff tried to kick out but Sting wouldn't let him. It's 2011 and we're supposed to believe that Sting shot on Jeff Hardy in a PPV main event a minute in. WITH HIS FUCKING FINISHER. Someone screamed something and Sting, on the ramp, looked at them and screamed, "I AGREE!" And that was the end of this show. Normally I wouldn't rate this, but we're on a roll with negative star matches so let's keep this alive. (-*****)

    ReplyDelete
  113. Yes, MINUS FIVE STARS. How do I justify this rating? Well, one of two things happened here. Maybe this whole thing was a stupid work. You know, the Pillman loose cannon deal with Hardy playing the role of wrestler-in-no-condition-to-perform, trying to get Internet fans talking. Well, if that's the case, this is the best they could come up with? If this was a work, and you were going to do this one-minute finish, at least have it go on second-to-last and come up with some creative excuse to put something else in the main event slot. Isn't that the point of having a CREATIVE TEAM? If this was a work they bent over and fucked in the ass their most die-hard, loyal-to-the-death fans with a 1:29 main event on a show they paid anywhere from $35 to $45 for. The other possibility is that Jeff was messed up, which was what people in TNA claimed Sunday night. In which case, why is Jeff Hardy in the main event? Years ago WWE fired Jeff because they were concerned with his behavior and he refused to go to rehab. TNA immediately signed him. Then when he kept fucking up they let him go, and WWE signed him back. Then he left WWE a second time, and a week later he got busted and CHARGED WITH MULTIPLE DRUG FELONIES. It's bad enough to bring a guy in who was having problems when working for the opposition (and believe me I am not defending WWE here because I thought it was wildly irresponsible when they did it as well), but to bring him in when he's facing possible jail time on drug charges? For fuck's sake. And it's not like they took a chance on him, like WWE did, and he actually was on his best behavior once he got there. Oh no. He had an incident just a few month back at another PPV where they were so concerned about his behavior backstage that they nearly pulled him from the show and stripped him of the title (and, of course, in the end they didn't, they just let him work, and then they gave the belt back to him again a month after he lost it to Mr. Anderson). HELLO? EARTH TO FUCKING IDIOTS. If this was legit, I have no sympathy for Dixie Carter whatsoever. In fact, I hold her even more responsible if this was real than if it was fake. If this was fake, they just did something ungodly stupid. If it was real, she continues to enable a guy with a real problem. She needs to get her fucking act together, like nine years ago. Not to mention that if he really was in no condition to perform, this was the best the creative team could come up with? A one-minute main event with a fluky finish? I mean, Jesus Christ, how long would it take you, the reader, to come up with something better, something that, I don't know, DOESN'T INVOLVE JEFF HARDY? I mean, think about this. Let's say he was under the influence of something. They actually thought – THEY ACTUALLY THOUGHT – that it would be better to PUT HIM IN THE RING FOR A ONE-MINUTE BULLSHIT MAIN EVENT than to, say, claim he got beat up by Kurt Angle and have Kurt replace him and do a 12-minute match with Sting. That decision right there, as a business owner, would cause me to swing low through this company in my sweet chariot, decapitating one member of creative after another with my flaming sword, so as to never see them again. Ideally everyone in the world would be employed, preferably in something they enjoyed doing, but for the love of God this company needs to die.

    ReplyDelete
  114. Just die, Dixie can go back to being the friendly receptionist at Panda Headquarters in Texas, and if fate is such that there must be a "number-two" wrestling company in America, someone with a fucking brain will come by and pick up the pieces. And hopefully they can do it without rehiring everyone responsible for this Titanic of a company, unlike the current moronic braintrust who hired everyone responsible for killing WCW almost exactly ten years ago to the day. Over the years I have gotten one angry letter after another from the TNA diehards, trying to defend the utter bullshit nonsense that is Impact and the stupid decisions Dixie and her goofy crew make. This is what happens when you blindly support bullshit. You get this show, a show destined to be an entire chapter in a book someday.

    ReplyDelete
  115. Finally... People has to realize that TNA totally SUCKS!

    ReplyDelete
  116. "And where are Meltzer's ratings?"

    If it's before 5 pm on the West Coast on Wednesday, the Observer isn't out yet.

    And "decapitating one member of creative after another with my flaming sword" is my new favorite Alvarez line. Even more so than his hate of Anderson's gum chewing.

    ReplyDelete
  117. Meltzer's Victory Road ratings:
    Tommy Dreamer vs. Bully Ray (Falls Count Anywhere Match) *1/2
    Angelina Love & Winter vs. Sarita & Rosita DUD
    Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan (First Blood Match) DUD
    Kazarian vs. Robbie E vs. Max Buck vs. Jeremy Buck (Ultimate X Match) **1/2
    Robert Roode & James Storm vs. Shannon Moore & Jesse Neal **3/4
    AJ Styles vs. Matt Hardy ***1/4
    Mr. Anderson vs. Rob Van Dam *1/4
    Sting vs. Jeff Hardy -*

    ReplyDelete
  118. Really? These are ratings? WTF? Ugh. Facepalm for giving Ult. X only **1/2 and RVD-Ken *1/4. Morgan-Hernadez DUD? Even bigger fpalm.

    ReplyDelete
  119. Morgan/Hernandez was a complete dud. Zero to like about that match. The UX was alright but nothing special. RVD/Ken was 100% boring and the ending was awful.

    ReplyDelete
  120. Morgan/Hernandez was a perfect example of why, if I ever win the lottery, I want to buy this company and sell it to Vince for about six cents. Just an absolute joke. A "DUD" is too good for it in my book.

    ReplyDelete
  121. Oh well then, let the WWE to continue to be the shitty PG borefest where Hornswoggle is a PRO and Michael Cole wrestles. Nothing against the guy, btw. Just tryin to make a point. Vince all over the wrestling world. Why is that so? Let's face it: 70% of today's 'wrestling' fans don't want TNA in the bussines. Why? Because they're all just dumb morons who even don't know the structure of wrestling bussines.

    Off, Morgan-Hernandez DUD? All because of that silly finish? Is that what these ratings are all about? Then fuck it.

    ReplyDelete
  122. To the last comment:
    If you aren't able to accept the ratings as their are given, why boring looking at this page? And I'm not always concur with Meltzer's (Brayn for that matter)rating of a match, but their are a value tool in the assessment of wrestling from an historical view. Of course WWE has have 5 stars macthes in last 12 years and of course some of the Japanese matches from the mid 90' that got ***** didn't deserve it; but that doesn't mean that the rating system is crap. It is what it is: a subjective matter... and whether you like it or not is the best thing going on!

    ReplyDelete
  123. What exactly is the best thing going on? just asking.

    ReplyDelete
  124. How do you know what percentage of wrestling fans want TNA in the business? Just asking.

    ReplyDelete
  125. I'm guessing. And you? Do you want TNA out of business? I'm sure you do because you're WWE 'fan'. Are you? Just asking.

    ReplyDelete
  126. I'm no more of a fan of the WWE than I'm of TNA. I'm a fan of substantiated statistics though. Hence, I'm not a fan of you.

    ReplyDelete
  127. Is Crimson 4life = Dixie Carter? Or it is Vince Russo?? 'Cause quiet frankly sounds like that. LOL.

    ReplyDelete
  128. TNA is a loose case. Instead on focusing their positives assets (and what could actually make different and stand from the rest, witch in turn will be reflected in ratings and ppv buy rates)their pretend to be a very low class WWE-type show, with almost no wrestling and a lot of boring-stupid-forgetful storytelling that usually result in nothing. STOP recreating NWO!!! It was good in 96' and it work for a few months until they burn it. Everybody knows that the guy who are "taking over" aren't. Sometimes the best new thing is going to the basic; ROH with their so-minor league appearance and crappy product presentation hasn't received that many bad reviews, nor it left the audience (the few they have)with that bullshit feeling at the end of the shows. The point is, put emphasis on what actually put you in the map: good wrestling. The ability of guys like AJ, Angle, Joe, beer money, MCMG, or even RVD should be the center of gravity of the promotion. Does anybody think that people are willing to pay to see Gunner/Murphy or Rob Terry perform? Does anybody believes in the Hogan-Carter saga?? Does somebody can relate to The Pope gimmick - whatever the hell it's suppose to be? NOOOO.

    ReplyDelete
  129. Oh the hell with this.....
    TNA Wrestling has legends. WWE has washed garbage(honor to some guys). And now they bring Snooki just because TNA has now connections with some Jersey Shore members. And yet, people are saying that TNA is copying WWE. And people are so frickin dump(and I mean dumb)and are saying that 3-3-11 is a ripoff. That's a pure parody and a clean message to WWE and all of fans that Stinger is still loyal to only TNA Wrestling.

    ReplyDelete
  130. >TNA Wrestling has legends. WWE has washed garbage

    Thanks for the laughs of the century...

    ReplyDelete
  131. "And now they bring Snooki just because TNA has now connections with some Jersey Shore members."

    What's more likely: that the WWE is going to pay to bring in Snooki for not only a Raw appearance but also Wrestlemania in order to attract mainstream attention or that the WWE is doing this JUST (which is the key word) because TNA did it and they want to play a game of "we can top that" with a company that doesn't do 10,000 PPV buys anymore. I have no issue with someone saying that it's BOTH; when someone says they are paying a celebrity to do multiple appearances just to screw with TNA, I'm not going to take that person very seriously when they talk about other people being dumb.

    Nor does it even really matter in the context of the topic here. Even if the WWE is doing this "just" because TNA did something similar, it doesn't make TNA one ounce better. It just distorts the issue. A valid answer to criticism is not to make the issue the WWE.

    As far as "IT'S A PARODY!": they are not mutually exclusive. You can do a parody of something and rip it off at the same time. Plenty of lazy creators can bite someone else's idea and claim it's a "parody". I'm not saying that TNA WAS lazy in this idea; just that this idea that the word "parody" somehow means it's not a rip off is weak.

    ReplyDelete
  132. Im'not saying that they're screwing TNA, but the hell with this, if TNA can bring some celebritys, we can also do that. They know they can bring in all the celebs in the USA, but they had to choose Jersey Shore star. That's my point. And yeah, WWE has that clown Jerry Lawler. He's that washed garbage that I'm talkin' about. Make no mistake, I'm also against Jeff Hardy and Dixie's family approach. And no doubt about that, the 3 3 11 thing was what I already said, the PARODY. One healthy brain can get that.

    ReplyDelete
  133. ...I wasn't arguing that it wasn't a parody.

    NEVERMIND. Nothing worthwhile is coming from this.

    ReplyDelete
  134. I know is just March, but the Hernandez, Sarita, Rosita and the other guy it a real contender mexican-revolutionaries is my winner most disgusting tactical promotion of the year and their match last week should be a nominee for worst worked match of the year. Let's see if WWE could top that! LOL

    ReplyDelete
  135. Any ratings for Lockdown? Angle vs JJ and The Lethal Lockdown was EPIC!

    TNA is being what always should be and Lockdown is the vent of the year till now.

    ReplyDelete
  136. Bryan's ratings for Lockdown:

    Chris Sabin vs. Robbie E vs. Jeremy Buck vs. Max Buck vs. Red vs. Jay Lethal vs. Brian Kendrick vs. Suicide (Xscape Cage Match) **3/4
    Ink Inc. vs. Eric Young & Orlando Jordan vs. Scott Steiner & Crimson vs. The British Invasion (Tornado Cage Match) **
    Mickie James vs. Madison Rayne (Title vs. Hair Cage Match) DUD
    Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Samoa Joe (Cage Match) **3/4
    Hernandez vs. Matt Morgan (Cage Match) **1/4
    Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett (2/3 Falls: Submission, Pinfall, Escape the Cage Match) ***3/4
    Sting vs. Rob Van Dam vs. Mr. Anderson *1/2
    Abyss, Ric Flair, Matt Hardy & Bully Ray vs. Beer Money, Christopher Daniels & Kazarian (Lethal Lockdown Match) ****

    ReplyDelete
  137. First of all, one question. How can a 30 second match be DUD? That's NR. It's not possible to rate. However, other ratings are solid, maybe except the Three Way and Joe-Pope. 3 Way **1/2 and Joe-Pope ***1/4. But all in all, fair ratings except DUD. Lockdown kicked ass!

    ReplyDelete
  138. There's a precedent for over twenty years in the Observer (as well as Figure Four) that "DUD" is applied to matches with no redeeming quality regardless of length. There's been matches A THIRD of the length of that match that has been given the same. This is nothing new.

    Meltzer's Lockdown ratings:
    Max Buck vs. Jay Lethal vs. Jeremy Buck vs. Amazing Red vs. Chris Sabin vs. Brian Kendrick vs. Suicide (Xscape Cage Match) *3/4
    Shannon Moore & Jesse Neal vs. Douglas Williams vs. Scott Steiner & Crimson vs. Orlando Jordan & Eric Young (Tornado Cage Match) **
    Mickie James vs. Madison Rayne (Title vs. Hair Cage Match) DUD
    Samoa Joe vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero (Cage Match) **1/2
    Matt Morgan vs. Hernandez (Cage Match) *1/2
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle (2/3 Falls: Submission, Pinfall, Escape the Cage Match) ****
    Sting vs. Mr. Anderson vs. Rob Van Dam (Cage Match) *1/2
    Robert Roode, James Storm, Kazarian & Christopher Daniels vs. Ric Flair, Matt Hardy, Abyss & Bully Ray (Lethal Lockdown Match) ****

    ReplyDelete
  139. Sacrifice ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  140. Bryan's:
    Ink Inc. vs. Mexican America 1/2*
    Brian Kendrick vs. Robbie E. *1/2
    Mickie James vs. Madison Rayne 1/2*
    Kazarian vs. Max Buck ***1/4
    Abyss vs. Crimson **1/4
    Beer Money vs. Matt Hardy & Chris Harris **1/2
    AJ Styles vs. Tommy Dreamer (No Disqualification Match) **1/2
    Karen & Jeff Jarrett vs. Kurt Angle & Chyna ***
    Sting vs. Rob Van Dam **3/4

    Meltzer:
    Hernandez & Anarquia vs. Shannon Moore & Jesse Neal *1/2
    Brian Kendrick vs. Robbie E. *1/4
    Mickie James vs. Madison Rayne *
    Kazarian vs. Max Buck **
    Crimson vs. Abyss *
    Beer Money vs. Matt Hardy & Chris Harris *1/4
    Tommy Dreamer vs. AJ Styles (No DQ Match) *1/2
    Kurt Angle & Chyna vs. Jeff & Karen Jarrett ***
    Sting vs. Rob Van Dam **3/4

    ReplyDelete
  141. Meltzer's ratings are extremely harsh. From Kaz/Buck to Styles/Dreamer are all at least a star below what they reasonably should be.

    ReplyDelete
  142. Dave Meltzer really underrated the Kaz/Buck match. That match was at least *** stars.

    ReplyDelete
  143. As the Iron Sheik would said: Fuck this!

    ReplyDelete
  144. Guys, does anybody know if Meltzer rated match between MMG and Apollo55 - for IWGP Jr. Tag-Titles in 2009?

    It was NJPW "New Japan Solo" tour.
    May 7th, 2009

    ReplyDelete
  145. sorry, not May 7th, but July 5th,)

    ReplyDelete
  146. slammiversary ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  147. Just read today's Observer, here are Meltzer's ratings for Slammiversary

    Alex Shelley/James Storm vs. Doug Williams/Magnus - ***
    Matt Morgan vs. Scott Steiner - *1/4
    Abyss vs. Brian Kendrick vs. Kazarian - 1/2*
    Crimson vs. Samoa Joe - 1/2*
    Mickie James vs. Angelina Love - DUD
    Bully Ray vs. AJ Styles (Last Man Standing) - ****
    Mr. Anderson vs. Sting - *3/4
    Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett - ***3/4

    ReplyDelete
  148. And Bryan's:

    Alex Shelley & James Storm vs. The British Invasion ***1/4
    Matt Morgan vs. Scott Steiner *1/4
    Abyss vs. Kazarian vs. Brian Kendrick DUD
    Samoa Joe vs. Crimson -*
    Mickie James vs. Angelina Love 1/2*
    AJ Styles vs. Bully Ray (Last Man Standing Match) ****
    Sting vs. Mr. Anderson NR? (Bryan gets carried away with his rantings and forgets to rate apparently)
    Kurt Angle vs. Jeff Jarrett ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  149. Correction: Samoa Joe vs. Crimson was just * not NEGATIVE *. I just left a dash in there by accident.

    ReplyDelete
  150. No >*** about the X Divisions matchs a Impact ?

    ReplyDelete
  151. Meltzer almost never rates Impact matches.

    ReplyDelete
  152. Yeah it takes a match of a really high magnitude or a good length on Impact for Meltzer to rate it: (IE: 10/15/09 AJ Styles vs. Kurt Angle ****1/4 which was their 20 minute draw)

    ReplyDelete
  153. Any ratings for DX? Fatal 4 Way was the 2nd best match of the year and Joe vs Kaz/ Aj vs Daniels and RVD vs Lynn were awesome too!

    ReplyDelete
  154. They should be posted later tonight.

    ReplyDelete
  155. This is going to be a two-issue week so ratings should be in tonight or tomorrow depending on which issue it's going to be in. Until then, here's Bryan's ratings:

    Destination X
    Kazarian vs. Samoa Joe ***1/2
    Douglas Williams vs. Mark Haskins **
    Max & Jeremy Buck vs. Shark Boy & Eric Young **1/4
    Robbie E. vs. Amazing Red vs. Alex Shelley vs. Shannon Moore (Ultimate X Match) ***1/2
    Jerry Lynn vs. Rob Van Dam ***1/2
    Low-Ki vs. Jack Evans vs. Zema Ion vs. Austin Aries ****
    Abyss vs. Brian Kendrick -*
    AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  156. And Meltzer's:
    Kazarian vs. Samoa Joe ***1/4
    Doug Williams vs. Mark Haskins *1/4
    Shark Boy & Eric Young vs. Generation Me *1/2
    Alex Shelley vs. Robbie E. vs. Shannon Moore vs. Amazing Red (Ultimate X Match) ***
    Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn ***
    Austin Aries vs. Zema Ion vs. Low Ki vs. Jack Evans ****
    Brian Kendrick vs. Abyss *1/4
    AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels ***3/4

    ReplyDelete
  157. Hardcore Justice ratings:

    Meltzer:
    Brian Kendrick vs. Alex Shelley vs. Austin Aries **3/4
    Tara & Miss Tessmacher vs. Rosita & Sarita 3/4*
    Pope D’Angelo Dinero vs. Devon *
    Winter vs. Mickie James -*
    Crimsonn vs. Rob Van Dam DUD
    AJ Styles, Kazarian & Christopher Daniels vs. Scott Steiner, Gunner & Abyss ***1/4
    Bully Ray vs. Mr. Anderson *3/4
    Bobby Roode & James Storm vs. Hernandez & Anarquia ***
    Kurt Angle vs. Sting ***1/2

    Bryan:
    Brian Kendrick vs. Austin Aries vs. Alex Shelley ***
    Tara & Miss Tessmacher vs. Sarita & Rosita *1/2
    Pope D'Angelo Dinero vs. Devon *1/2
    Mickie James vs. Winter *1/4
    Rob Van Dam vs. Crimson *1/2
    Christopher Daniels, AJ Styles & Kazarian vs. Gunner, Abyss & Scott Steiner ***
    Mr. Anderson vs. Bully Ray **1/4
    Beer Money vs. Mexican America **3/4
    Sting vs. Kurt Angle ***

    ReplyDelete
  158. No Surrender ratings:

    Meltzer:
    Jesse Sorensen vs. Kid Kash **1/2
    Bully Ray vs. James Storm *1/2
    Winter vs. Mickie James *1/4
    Hernandez & Anarquia vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero & Devon *1/2
    Matt Morgan vs. Samoa Joe **3/4
    Bobby Roode vs. Gunner ***
    Austin Aries vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/4
    Bobby Roode vs. Bully Ray **1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. Mr. Anderson vs. Sting *1/4

    Bryan:
    Kid Kash vs. Jesse Soresen *1/2
    James Storm vs. Bully Ray NR?
    Winter vs. Mickie James DUD
    Mexican America vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero & Devon *3/4
    Samoa Joe vs. Matt Morgan *3/4
    Bobby Roode vs. Gunner **
    Brian Kendrick vs. Austin Aries **3/4
    Bobby Roode vs. Bully Ray **1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. Sting vs. Mr. Anderson *1/2

    ReplyDelete
  159. Meltzer gave Storm/Angle from Impact last week ***3/4


    Angle and Storm went to a no contest in 11:30 . This was a ***3/4 match. Just a great
    TV bout and if they play it up right, this should be the elevation of Storm into the
    main event singles tier. Angle took that crazy back drop over the top rope to the
    floor. He looks so out of control going over that he’s going to kill himself doing it
    some day. Angle gave Storm a belly-to-belly on the ramp. Storm did a smooth transition
    into a back stabber. Angle with the ankle lock. Storm kicked Angle off. Angle went for
    a charge, missed and flew into the corner. After a blocked superkick Angle did three
    German suplexes for a near fall. He missed a moonsault and then Storm did the Randy
    Savage elbow off the top for a near fall. I get it in WWE, but why in TNA does nobody
    mention Randy Savage? Gunner came out and distracted Storm. Angle hit the Olympic slam
    but Storm kicked out. Storm went for a superkick, but Angle ducked and it hit Brian
    Hebner. Storm superkicked Angle but no ref. Earl Hebner ran out to count but Gunner
    pulled Earl out of the ring. Gunner hit Storm with a belt shot and was beating on
    him. Roode did a run-in for the save. Roode ended up looking at the belt and admiring
    it, and then placed it on the ground so Angle could pick it up.

    ReplyDelete
  160. then Storm did the Randy
    Savage elbow off the top for a near fall. I get it in WWE, but why in TNA does nobody
    mention Randy Savage?

    I cannot remember anyone in WWE mentioning Macho Man minus a small tribute.

    ReplyDelete
  161. That was his point, the fact that Savage is not mentioned in WWE, I assume he thinks that TNA should take advantage of their situation and mention him.

    ReplyDelete
  162. Bound for Glory ratings:

    Meltzer:
    Austin Aries vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn (Full Metal Mayhem Match) ***1/4
    Crimson vs. Samoa Joe vs. Matt Morgan **1/4
    Mr. Anderson vs. Bully Ray (Falls Count Anywhere Match) ***1/2
    Velvet Sky vs. Winter vs. Mickie James vs. Madison Rayne DUD
    AJ Styles vs. Christopher Daniels (I Quit Match) *3/4
    Sting vs. Hulk Hogan ***
    Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Roode ***

    Bryan:
    Mexican America vs. Ink Inc. **1/2
    Austin Aries vs. Brian Kendrick ***1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Jerry Lynn (Full Metal Mayhem Match) **3/4
    Samoa Joe vs. Matt Morgan vs. Crimson **
    Bully Ray vs. Mr. Anderson (Falls Count Anywhere Match) ***1/4
    Winter vs. Mickie James vs. Velvet Sky vs. Madison Rayne -**
    Christopher Daniels vs. AJ Styles (I Quit Match) **1/4
    Hulk Hogan vs. Sting *1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. Bobby Roode ***

    ReplyDelete
  163. Wait Meltzer gave Hogan vs Sting 3 stars? That has to be a typo, right?

    ReplyDelete
  164. Nope. I even had to read it twice to make sure I wasn't imaging things. I guess this is what happens when you go into a match with INCREDIBLY low expectations.

    ReplyDelete
  165. I'd imagine he gave the star rating based more off the whole segment (which was by far the best part of the show).

    ReplyDelete
  166. He apparently gave Low Ki/Jerry Lynn from 7/31/02 ***1/2.

    ReplyDelete
  167. Turning Point ratings:

    Bryan:
    Eric Young vs. Robbie E. *1/2
    Mexican America & Sarita vs. Ink Inc. & Toxine *3/4
    Austin Aries vs. Kid Kash vs. Jesse Sorensen **1/2
    Christopher Daniels vs. Rob Van Dam (No DQ Match) ***
    Matt Morgan vs. Crimson &
    Mr. Anderson & Abyss vs. Scott Steiner & Bully Ray **1/2
    Velvet Sky vs. Gail Kim DUD
    Jeff Jarrett vs. Jeff Hardy **1/4
    Bobby Roode vs. AJ Styles ***1/4

    Meltzer:
    Robbie E. vs. Eric Young *1/4
    Hernandez, Anarquia & Sarita vs. Jesse Neal, Shannon Moore & Toxine *3/4
    Austin Aries vs. Jesse Sorensen vs. Kid Kash **1/2
    Rob Van Dam vs. Christopher Daniels (No DQ Match) **1/4
    Crimson vs. Matt Morgan 3/4*
    Mr. Anderson & Abyss vs. Scott Steiner & Bully Ray **
    Gail Kim vs. Velvet Sky 1/2*
    Jeff Hardy vs. Jeff Jarrett **
    Bobby Roode vs. AJ Styles **3/4

    First show in a while that I can recall a show that didn't have a single *** match from Meltzer.

    ReplyDelete
  168. Ouch. I would have thought the 3 way, RVD/Daniels and the main event would have broken it. Crimson/Morgan being anything higher than a DUD is an insult.

    ReplyDelete
  169. By the way, Bryan gave Matt Morgan vs. Crimson *. Typo on original post.

    ReplyDelete
  170. Não consigo acreditar que Pope vs Samoa Joe no Lockdown foi ** 1/4.. Era pra ter sido no minimo *** 1/2!

    ReplyDelete
  171. Are Final Resolution '11 ratings out?

    ReplyDelete
  172. Meltzer:
    Rob Van Dam vs. Christopher Daniels *3/4
    Robbie E. vs. Eric Young *1/2
    Matt Morgan & Crimson vs. Pope D’Angelo Dinero & Devon *
    Austin Aries vs. Kid Kash **1/2
    Gail Kim vs. Mickie James **1/4
    James Storm vs. Kurt Angle ***1/4
    Jeff Hardy vs. Jeff Jarrett (Cage Match) ***1/4
    Bobby Roode vs. AJ Styles (30-Minute Iron Man Match) ***1/2

    Bryan:
    Rob Van Dam vs. Christopher Daniels *3/4
    Robbie E. vs. Eric Young *1/2
    Crimson & Matt Morgan vs. vs. Pope D'Angelo Dinero & Devon 1/2*
    Austin Aries vs. Kid Kash ***
    Gail Kim vs. Mickie James **1/2
    Kurt Angle vs. James Storm ***
    Jeff Hardy vs. Jeff Jarrett (Cage Match) **1/2
    Bobby Roode vs. AJ Styles (30-Minute Iron Man Match) ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  173. Ratings for Genesis 2012

    Dave:

    Aries vs Sorensen vs Kash vs Ion ***
    Devon vs Pope ***
    Gunner vs RVD **1/2
    Gail vs Mickie **1/4
    Abyss vs Bully Ray *
    Morgan & Crimson vs Samoa Joe & Magnus *3/4
    Angle vs Storm **1/4
    Hardy vs Roode **1/2

    Bryan:

    Aries vs Sorensen vs Kash vs Ion **1/2
    Pope vs Devon **1/4
    Gunner vs RVD *1/2
    Gail vs Mickie *1/4
    Bully vs Abyss NR?
    Morgan & Crimson vs Magnus & Joe **
    Angle vs Storm *1/2
    Roode vs Hardy **3/4

    ReplyDelete
  174. So Meltzer by that thought that Pope/Devon was tied for best match of the show? He's losing it.

    ReplyDelete
  175. So Will, Observer awards and thankfully Tanahashi won. Can you please tell me the rest of the top 5 in the voting for Wrestler of the Year, Best Technical Wrestler, Most Outstanding Wrestler, Match of the Year, Feud of the Year and Best Major Show. Also any notes like last year if anything surprising of note came up.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Top Fives (numbers in parenthesis are the total number of first places votes, the other number the total points each received based on the 5-3-2 scoring.

      Wrestler of the Year
      1. HIROSHI TANAHASHI (417) 2,718

      2. C.M. Punk (248) 2,102

      3. John Cena (68) 946

      4. Masaaki Mochizuki (9) 493

      5. Randy Orton (2) 388

      Best Technical Wrestler
      1. DANIEL BRYAN (263) 1,829

      2. Davey Richards (247) 1,655

      3. Prince Devitt (30) 910

      4. Yuji Nagata (29) 590

      5. Eddie Edwards (13) 568

      Most Outstanding Wrestler
      1. DAVEY RICHARDS (201) 1,511

      2. Hiroshi Tanahashi (165) 1,112

      3. Daniel Bryan (104) 948

      4. Prince Devitt (5) 785

      5. El Generico (67) 598

      Match of the Year
      1. JOHN CENA VS. C.M. PUNK 7/17 CHICAGO (333) 2,292

      2. Eddie Edwards vs. Davey Richards 6/26 New York (112) 1,362

      3. HHH vs. Undertaker 4/3 Atlanta (51) 890

      4. Jun Akiyama vs. Suwama 10/23 Tokyo (75) 808

      5. Hiroshi Tanahashi vs. Yuji Nagata 4/3 Tokyo (39) 538

      Feud of the Year
      1. JOHN CENA VS. C.M. PUNK (190) 1,551

      2. Randy Orton vs. Christian (74) 747

      3. Davey Richards vs. Eddie Edwards (61) 701

      4. Blood Warriors vs. Junction Three (75) 673

      5. Kevin Steen vs. ROH (56) 485

      Best Major Show
      1. WWE MONEY IN THE BANK 7/17 CHICAGO (374) 2,391

      2. UFC 139 11/19 San Jose (40) 700

      3. ROH Best in the World 6/26 New York (32) 542

      4. ROH Final Battle 12/18/10 New York (15) 483

      5. PWG DDT 4 3/4 Reseda (24) 378

      Delete
  176. Bryan just gave the ratings for Against All Odds

    Zema Ion vs Sorensen NR.
    Robbie E vs Shannon Moore **1/4
    Tara vs Gail Kim **3/4
    Crimson & Morgan vs Samoa Joe & Magnus *3/4
    Aries vs Shelley ****
    Kazarian vs AJ Styles **1/2
    Gunner vs Garrett Bischoff NEGATIVE**
    Roode vs Ray vs Hardy vs Storm NEGATIVE **

    ReplyDelete
  177. Dave ratings:

    Ion vs Sorensen NR
    Robbie E vs Moore *1/2
    Gail vs Tara **1/4
    Joe/Magnus vs Crimson/Morgan *3/4
    Aries vs Shelley ***1/2
    Kazarian vs AJ **3/4
    Gunner vs Garrett 1/2*
    Roode vs Ray vs Hardy vs Storm *3/4

    ReplyDelete
  178. Bryan's Victory Road Ratings:

    Storm vs Ray *
    Aries vs Ion ***1/4
    Crimson & Morgan vs Joe & Magnus *1/2
    Robbie E vs Devon **
    Gail Kim vs Madison Rayne 1/4*
    AJ & Anderson vs Daniels/Kazarian ***3/4
    Angle vs Hardy **3/4
    Sting vs Roode **1/2

    P.D. I thought Bryan was way too harsh with Angle vs Hardy, for me it was a very good match.

    ReplyDelete
  179. I think the rating for angle/hardy was wrong. He called it the best match of the whole show. Probably got that and the AJ tag backwards.

    ReplyDelete
  180. Dave ratings for Victory Road:

    Storm vs Ray NR
    Aries vs Ion **3/4
    Joe & Magnus vs Morgan & Crimson *1/4
    Devon vs Robbie E *
    Kim vs Rayne 1/4*
    AJ & Anderson vs Daniels & Kazarian ***1/4
    Angle vs Hardy ***3/4
    Roode vs Sting ***1/4

    ReplyDelete
  181. Bryan ratings for Lockdown

    Lethal Lockdown match: *1/4
    Joe & Magnus vs MCMG *1/2
    Robbie E vs Devon **
    Gail Kim vs Velvet 1/2*
    Crimson vs Morgan *3/4
    Hardy vs Angle ***1/2
    Young & ODB vs Rosita & Sarita *
    Roode vs Storm **3/4

    ReplyDelete
  182. Dave ratings:

    Lethal Lockdown: *1/2
    Joe & Magnus vs MCMG **1/4
    Devon vs Robbie E 3/4*
    Gail Kim vs Velvet Sky 1/2*
    Crimson vs Morgan 3/4*
    Hardy vs Angle ***3/4
    Young & ODB vs Sarita & Rosita 3/4*
    Roode vs Storm ***1/2

    ReplyDelete
  183. Sacrifice ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  184. Meltzer
    Magnus & Joe/Kazarian & Daniels ***1/4
    Gail Kim/Brooke Tessmacher **1/4
    Robbie T/Robbie E/Devon *1/4
    Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson *1/4
    Crimson/Eric Young 3/4*
    Bully Ray/Austin Aries ***1/2
    Kurt Angle/AJ Styles ****
    Bobby Roode/Rob Van Dam ***3/4

    Alvarez
    Magnus & Joe/Kazarian & Daniels **3/4
    Gail Kim/Brooke Tessmacher *3/4
    Robbie T/Robbie E/Devon **1/2
    Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson **
    Crimson/Eric Young *1/2
    Bully Ray/Austin Aries ****
    Kurt Angle/AJ Styles ***1/4
    Bobby Roode/Rob Van Dam **3/4

    ReplyDelete
  185. Anonymous posted. i don't believe in anonymous...

    /justkidding

    ReplyDelete
  186. **** for Austin Aries vs Bully Ray? LOL

    ReplyDelete
  187. TNA Slammiversary Ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  188. Slammiversary Ratings??

    ReplyDelete
  189. Meltzer
    Samoa Joe/Austin Aries ***3/4
    Hernandez/Kid Kash **1/2
    Devon & Garett Bischoff/Robbie E & Robbie T *3/4
    Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson/Rob Van Dam ***
    James Storm/Crimson *
    Miss Tessmacher/Gail Kim *1/4
    Bully Ray/Joseph Park *1/2
    Kurt Angle & AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels & Kazarian ****1/4
    Bobby Roode/Sting **

    Alvarez
    Sam
    Samoa Joe/Austin Aries ***1/2
    Hernandez/Kid Kash **1/2
    Devon & Garett Bischoff/Robbie E & Robbie T *1/4
    Jeff Hardy/Mr. Anderson/Rob Van Dam ***
    James Storm/Crimson *1/2
    Miss Tessmacher/Gail Kim *
    Bully Ray/Joseph Park ***1/4
    Kurt Angle & AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels & Kazarian ****
    Bobby Roode/Sting **1/2

    ReplyDelete
  190. Destination X ratings?

    ReplyDelete
  191. I don't think Alvarez's are up yet but here are Dave's

    Mason Andrews/Dakota Darsow/Rubix/Lars Only *1/4
    Mason Andrews/Kid Kash **
    Kenny King/Douglas Williams **1/4
    Sonjay Dutt/Rashad Cameron **1/2
    Zema Ion/Flip Cassanova *
    Samoa Joe/Kurt Angle ***3/4
    AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels ****1/4
    Zema Ion/Mason Andrews/Sonjay Dutt/Kenny King ***1/4
    Austin Aries/Bobby Roode ****1/2

    ReplyDelete
  192. Alvarez's
    Mason Andrews/Dakota Darsow/Rubix/Lars Only **1/4
    Mason Andrews/Kid Kash **1/4
    Kenny King/Douglas Williams *3/4
    Sonjay Dutt/Rashad Cameron **1/2
    Zema Ion/Flip Cassanova *1/2
    Samoa Joe/Kurt Angle ***1/4
    AJ Styles/Christopher Daniels ****
    Zema Ion/Mason Andrews/Sonjay Dutt/Kenny King **3/4
    Austin Aries/Bobby Roode ****1/4

    ReplyDelete